Question

Difficulty: HardMost Strongly Supported Questions

Paleoclimatologists measure the ratio of oxygen-18 to oxygen-16 in the calcium carbonate shells of benthic foraminifera found in deep-sea sediment cores. Because water molecules containing the lighter oxygen-16 isotope evaporate more readily from the oceans and are subsequently trapped in continental ice sheets during glacial periods, a higher ratio of oxygen-18 to oxygen-16 in these deep-sea shells indicates a larger global ice volume at the time the shells were formed. Furthermore, the analysis of cores from the North Atlantic shows that during the last three glacial periods, the peak oxygen-18 to oxygen-16 ratio was reached approximately 5,000 years before the minimum sea surface temperatures were recorded in the same region. Which of the following statements are most strongly supported by the information above? (Select all that apply)

  1. During periods of extensive global glaciation, the ocean water from which benthic foraminifera construct their shells contains a lower concentration of oxygen-16 relative to oxygen-18 than it does during interglacial periods.Answer
  2. In the North Atlantic, the maximum extent of global ice volume during the last three glacial periods occurred before the ocean surface waters reached their coldest temperatures.Answer
  3. C
    The calcium carbonate shells of benthic foraminifera formed during interglacial periods contain a higher total absolute quantity of oxygen-16 than those formed during glacial periods.
  4. D
    The trapping of oxygen-16 in continental ice sheets is the primary cause of the decrease in sea surface temperatures in the North Atlantic during glacial periods.
  5. E
    All deep-sea marine organisms that construct calcium carbonate shells exhibit the exact same oxygen isotope ratios as benthic foraminifera from the corresponding time periods.

Answer

The correct statements are that ocean water has a lower relative concentration of oxygen-16 during glaciations, and that the maximum global ice volume preceded the coldest ocean surface temperatures in the North Atlantic.
The correct choices directly follow from synthesizing the provided facts. First, because oxygen-16 is trapped in ice during glacial periods, the ocean water must logically have a lower concentration of oxygen-16 relative to oxygen-18 than it normally would. Second, because the peak isotope ratio indicates maximum ice volume, and this peak occurs 5,000 years before minimum temperatures, the maximum ice volume must occur before the ocean reaches its coldest temperatures.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the causal mechanism for isotope ratios.
Oxygen-16 evaporates and gets trapped in ice, leaving the oceans with a higher ratio of oxygen-18 to oxygen-16.
This establishes why deep-sea shells show different ratios during glacial versus interglacial periods.
2
Analyze the timeline presented in the text.
The peak isotope ratio (indicating maximum ice volume) happens roughly 5,000 years before the minimum sea surface temperatures.
This establishes the temporal sequence of events during the last three glacial periods.
3
Evaluate the choices against the strictly supported facts.
Only choices dealing with relative concentrations (ratios) and the timeline of events are supported. Choices dealing with absolute numbers, unstated causal relationships, or generalizations to other organisms are unsupported.
Most Strongly Supported questions require answers that can be proven or heavily deduced directly from the text without outside assumptions.

Key Concept

Synthesizing explicit premises to form a highly probable conclusion while avoiding ratio versus absolute amount and causation fallacies.
Rate this question