Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardExplicit Main Point Identification

Read the following passage.

Traditional historical linguistics relies heavily on the family tree model, which categorizes languages based on genetic descent from a single common ancestor. Under this paradigm, linguists have historically attempted to classify creole languages—which emerge from extended contact between groups lacking a common language—by assigning them to the language family of their primary lexifier, the language providing the bulk of their vocabulary. However, this approach is fundamentally flawed. Because creole formation is inherently a process of complex synthesis rather than linear descent, attempting to force creoles into traditional phylogenetic trees obscures the unique, multidirectional sociolinguistic dynamics that actually drive their creation. While a creole may borrow up to ninety percent of its lexicon from a dominant European language, its grammatical structure often draws heavily from the substrate languages of marginalized groups or develops entirely novel syntactic features to facilitate immediate cross-cultural communication. To classify Haitian Creole merely as a "French dialect" based on vocabulary is to ignore the profound African grammatical influences and the spontaneous linguistic innovation that define its true origin.

Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

  1. A
    Creole languages typically derive the bulk of their vocabulary from a single dominant language while simultaneously adopting grammatical structures from marginalized substrate languages.
  2. Attempting to classify creole languages using the traditional family tree model is inappropriate because such linear models obscure the complex, synthetic nature of creole formation.Answer
  3. C
    Traditional historical linguists recognize that the family tree model must be radically restructured to account for the multidirectional dynamics that drive the creation of creole languages.
  4. D
    Because Haitian Creole features profound spontaneous linguistic innovation, linguists must abandon the family tree model when classifying any language with a heavily borrowed lexicon.
  5. E
    The traditional family tree model of historical linguistics is fundamentally flawed and should be discarded entirely because it fails to accurately describe the sociolinguistic evolution of modern languages.

Answer

The correct answer asserts that attempting to classify creole languages using the traditional family tree model is inappropriate because linear models obscure the complex, synthetic nature of creole formation.
The correct answer directly paraphrases the author's explicitly stated thesis. In the middle of the passage, the author states that forcing creoles into traditional phylogenetic trees is flawed because it obscures the 'multidirectional sociolinguistic dynamics' (the synthetic nature) of their formation. This option captures both the author's stance against the traditional model's application to creoles and the specific reason for that stance.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the structure of the passage to separate background context from the author's primary argument.
The first two sentences describe the 'traditional' approach to classifying creoles. The third and fourth sentences introduce a pivot ('However, this approach is fundamentally flawed') and state a direct thesis about why.
Identifying the structural pivot helps locate the explicitly stated main point, distinguishing the author's voice from the viewpoints they are critiquing.
2
Identify the explicit thesis statement.
The thesis is explicitly stated as: 'Because creole formation is inherently a process of complex synthesis rather than linear descent, attempting to force creoles into traditional phylogenetic trees obscures the unique, multidirectional sociolinguistic dynamics that actually drive their creation.'
The question specifically asks for the main point, which in this passage is explicitly articulated after the description of the traditional model.
3
Evaluate the options against the identified thesis.
The correct option paraphrases the explicit thesis, capturing both the rejection of the traditional model for creoles and the rationale (complex synthesis vs. linear descent).
The correct answer must accurately reflect the scope and content of the author's main conclusion without being too broad or focusing only on supporting details.

Key Concept

Explicit Main Point Identification
Rate this question

Topics

Explicit Main Point Identification

More questions from this topic