Sufficient Assumption
42 questions
Ecologist: Any agricultural system that integrates deep-rooted perennial woody vegetation with livestock grazing significantly reduces nitrate leaching into local aquifers. Moreover, any farming method that significantly reduces nitrate leaching into local aquifers qualifies as an environmentally restorative practice. Therefore, every farm that implements rotational silvopastoral management qualifies as an environmentally restorative practice.
The ecologist's conclusion follows logically if which one of the following is assumed?
Environmental Policy Analyst: Any geothermal power station that utilizes closed-loop supercritical fluid extraction achieves an operational thermal efficiency exceeding forty percent. Furthermore, no geothermal facility operating at an efficiency exceeding forty percent qualifies for regional groundwater conservation credits unless it reinjects all extracted mineral condensates into deep sub-surface basalt formations. The North Ridge geothermal facility was recently awarded regional groundwater conservation credits. Therefore, the North Ridge facility does not utilize closed-loop supercritical fluid extraction.
The environmental policy analyst's conclusion follows logically if which one of the following is assumed?
Archivist: Any parchment document treated with nano-cellulose spray creates an airtight molecular barrier. Furthermore, any document that possesses an airtight molecular barrier resists microbial ink erosion. Since the fourteenth-century guild charter was treated with nano-cellulose spray, it is certain to be approved for permanent display in the main rotunda.
The archivist's conclusion follows logically if which one of the following is assumed?
An architectural acoustician constructs a deductive argument evaluating a newly designed performance venue. Complete the argument by identifying the missing premise that guarantees the conclusion follows logically and necessarily.
Fill in the blanks below
Premise 2: Every performance venue that produces low-frequency standing waves is unsuitable for recording vocal polyphony.
Missing Premise: The Lyceum Auditorium .
Conclusion: Therefore, the Lyceum Auditorium is unsuitable for recording vocal polyphony.
For each of the incomplete arguments in the left column, select the missing premise from the right column that, if assumed, allows the argument's conclusion to be properly drawn.
Click a left item, then click its matching right item
Items
Matches
Botanist: Any alpine plant that undergoes early budburst without a corresponding increase in foliar cuticle thickness will suffer extensive cellular necrosis if exposed to unseasonal late-spring freezes. Furthermore, any plant that suffers extensive cellular necrosis from late-spring freezes will experience a reduction in lifetime seed viability below the replacement threshold unless it can activate dormant meristem tissue. Southern dwarf willows invariably undergo early budburst in response to early-season warming, yet they completely lack dormant meristem tissue. Therefore, if unseasonal late-spring freezes occur in their habitat, southern dwarf willows will experience a reduction in lifetime seed viability below the replacement threshold.
The botanist's conclusion follows logically if which one of the following is assumed?
Urban Planner: Any historic district redevelopment proposal that mandates permeable stone pavements will significantly reduce seasonal urban stormwater runoff. Furthermore, every redevelopment proposal that significantly reduces seasonal urban stormwater runoff helps lower downstream municipal infrastructure costs. Therefore, any historic district redevelopment proposal that mandates permeable stone pavements will be granted expedited zoning authorization by the city council.
The conclusion of the urban planner's argument follows logically if which one of the following is assumed?
Ethics Analyst: Any algorithmic underwriting model that evaluates borrower risk primarily through secondary transaction data inevitably relies on unverified behavioral proxies. Furthermore, any underwriting model that relies on unverified behavioral proxies fails to satisfy the regulatory threshold for fair lending practices. Thus, any algorithmic underwriting model adopted by sovereign credit unions will fail to satisfy the regulatory threshold for fair lending practices.
The ethics analyst's conclusion follows logically if which one of the following is assumed?
Complete the archaeometrist's formal deductive argument by identifying the missing premise that logically guarantees the conclusion.
Fill in the blanks below
Premise 2:
Conclusion: Therefore, every artifact unearthed at the Oakhaven kiln complex was fired at temperatures exceeding 900°C.
Cognitive Ethologist: Ravens in subarctic habitats reliably adjust their food-caching strategies depending on whether they were observed by dominant conspecifics, which demonstrates intentional deception. Any animal that exhibits intentional deception must have the capacity for second-order mental representation. Therefore, subarctic ravens possess a theory of mind.
The cognitive ethologist's conclusion follows logically if which one of the following is assumed?
Match each incomplete argument on the left with the sufficient assumption on the right that logically guarantees its conclusion. Which sufficient assumption properly completes each argument?
Click a left item, then click its matching right item
Items
Premise: Any environmental mitigation policy that relies on voluntary corporate compliance inevitably fails to produce verifiable reductions in particulate emissions.
Conclusion: Thus, the municipal clean air initiative will fail to qualify for federal regulatory subsidies.
Premise: Any biomedical clinical trial that utilizes synthetic control groups rather than randomized human controls cannot establish statistical equivalence across diverse subpopulations.
Conclusion: Thus, the experimental immunotherapy protocol should not receive expedited regulatory approval.
Premise: Any algorithmic judicial sentencing tool that optimizes solely for recidivism reduction disproportionately weighs prior arrest records over severity of conviction.
Conclusion: Thus, the state correctional board's automated sentencing model systematically violates statutory parity mandates.
Matches
An astrobiologist constructs a formal deductive argument to establish the habitability potential of a planetary body. Complete the argument by identifying the missing premise that logically and deductively guarantees the truth of the conclusion.
Fill in the blanks below
Premise 2: The benthic floor of the Kraken Mare basin exhibits active serpentinization.
Premise 3: Any geological formation that produces continuous alkaline fluid emissions is .
Conclusion: Therefore, the benthic floor of the Kraken Mare basin is viable for prebiotic amino acid synthesis.
Archivist: Any digital archiving project that utilizes proprietary file formats will eventually require format migration to maintain public accessibility. However, migrating complex digital records across different formats invariably introduces some data degradation. Therefore, no archiving project that maintains perfect record fidelity can utilize proprietary file formats.
The archivist's conclusion follows logically if which one of the following is assumed?
Ecologist: Any wetlands conservation initiative that permanently elevates local water tables prevents the microbial decomposition of subterranean peat. Preventing the microbial decomposition of subterranean peat guarantees that a wetland will not release methane into the atmosphere. The wetlands conservation project in the Millford Basin will permanently elevate local water tables. Thus, the Millford Basin project will contribute to a net decrease in atmospheric greenhouse gas concentrations.
The ecologist's conclusion follows logically if which one of the following is assumed?
Complete the formal deductive argument below by filling in the missing conditional bridge assumption so that the conclusion follows logically from the stated premises.
Fill in the blanks below
Premise 2: Any translation system that produces semantic drift fails the benchmark for diplomatic certification.
Missing Assumption: Any system that is prohibited from official treaty documentation.
Conclusion: Therefore, any automated translation engine that lacks context-sensitive disambiguation is prohibited from official treaty documentation.
Urban Planner: Any municipal zoning policy that restricts high-density commercial developments within transit corridors inadvertently reduces public transit ridership. Furthermore, no policy that reduces public transit ridership can effectively lower a city's net carbon emissions from passenger vehicles. Therefore, the municipal council's newly enacted downtown zoning policy will not effectively lower the city's net carbon emissions from passenger vehicles.
The conclusion of the urban planner's argument follows logically if which one of the following is assumed?
Bioethicist: A clinical medical trial is ethically permissible only if it prioritizes patient welfare above the pursuit of scientific discovery. Furthermore, a trial prioritizes patient welfare only if its participants are not subjected to disproportionate physiological risks. Unfortunately, obtaining statistically robust efficacy data in early-stage oncology trials invariably requires administering drug dosages that approach maximum tolerated toxic thresholds. Consequently, none of the early-stage oncology trials currently underway at the Apex Research Institute are ethically permissible.
The conclusion drawn by the bioethicist follows logically if which one of the following is assumed?
Paleoclimatologist: Validating any predictive model of rapid hemispheric glaciation necessitates either an uninterrupted stratigraphic record of deep-sea sediment cores or a precise quantification of atmospheric aerosol concentrations during the transition epoch. However, a precise quantification of these aerosol concentrations is strictly contingent upon the recovery of pristine ice cores from the corresponding period. Dr. Halley’s latest predictive model regarding the onset of the Younger Dryas anomaly has been conclusively validated. Yet, glaciological surveys confirm that all ice cores from the Younger Dryas transition epoch were irreparably contaminated by subsequent thermal maximums. Therefore, Dr. Halley must have been granted access to the classified geological archives held by the Nordic Subsea Consortium.
The conclusion drawn by the paleoclimatologist follows logically if which one of the following is assumed?
Analyze the structural gaps in the following deductive arguments. Match each incomplete argument with the specific conditional premise (sufficient assumption) that, if added, would logically guarantee its conclusion.
Click a left item, then click its matching right item
Items
Matches
Read the formal argument below and determine the exact missing premise that logically completes the deduction.
Fill in the blanks below
Complete the required sufficient assumption that guarantees the conclusion:
The architecture fails to strictly utilize quantum-resistant .