Question

Difficulty: Very hardConfidentiality and Information Security

A practical nurse (PN) is providing discharge instructions to a competent, alert client who is accompanied by their adult child. The client's medical record contains a signed authorization form permitting the facility to share health information with this child. While discussing the home medication regimen, the child suddenly asks the PN, "Did the admission blood tests show that my parent was using illicit drugs?" The client becomes visibly tense, looks away, and remains silent. What is the most appropriate action for the PN to take?

  1. Request that the child step out of the room briefly to privately confirm the client's wishes regarding this disclosure.Answer
  2. B
    Disclose the laboratory findings since the child is explicitly listed as an authorized recipient on the signed consent form.
  3. C
    Inform the child that providing toxicology results falls outside the practical nurse's scope of practice.
  4. D
    State that admission laboratory results cannot be discussed because they are unrelated to the current discharge instructions.

Answer

The nurse should ask the child to temporarily leave the room so the nurse can privately ascertain whether the client consents to sharing this sensitive information.
Although the child is listed on the signed authorization form, a competent client retains the right to control their protected health information and can limit or revoke consent at any time. The client's non-verbal cues indicate acute discomfort with the question. By asking the child to step out, the nurse acts as a client advocate, providing a safe, private environment for the client to express their true wishes without coercion or pressure from the family member.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the clinical scenario and the legal documentation regarding the release of protected health information.
The child is an authorized recipient on paper, but the client is competent, present, and exhibiting non-verbal signs of distress in response to the question.
Written authorization allows for the sharing of information but does not mandate it. A competent client retains the right to restrict disclosures in real-time.
2
Identify the priority nursing obligation regarding client advocacy and privacy.
The nurse must ensure the client's immediate right to privacy is protected and that true consent is established without familial coercion.
Asking the client to confirm their consent in front of the child might pressure the client into agreeing. A private conversation ensures true, uncoerced autonomy.

Key Concept

Client autonomy and dynamic consent regarding protected health information
Rate this question