Question

Difficulty: HardConfidentiality and Information Security

During a home health visit, a practical nurse (PN) is caring for a client recovering from a mild stroke. The client is currently resting in the bedroom, but remains fully alert and oriented when awake. The client's adult child, who is visiting to assist with household chores, asks the PN for a printed copy of the client's current medication list to help organize a weekly pill organizer. The adult child is not designated as a healthcare proxy and is not listed on the client's authorized disclosure form. Which of the following is the most appropriate action for the PN to take?

  1. Wait for the client to awaken and ask for their direct verbal permission before sharing the medication list.Answer
  2. B
    Provide the printed list to the adult child because they are an immediate family member involved in the client's daily care.
  3. C
    Inform the adult child that they must legally obtain healthcare proxy status before any medical information can be disclosed.
  4. D
    Verbally review the medication names and dosages with the adult child instead of handing over the official printed document.

Answer

Wait for the client to awaken and ask for their direct verbal permission before sharing the medication list.
Under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), a competent client has the right to control who receives their protected health information (PHI). Because the client in this scenario is alert and oriented, they retain full authority over their medical records. Since the client is currently asleep and this is not a medical emergency, the nurse must wait for the client to awaken to obtain their verbal consent before sharing the medication list with the adult child. Verbal consent given by a competent client in the moment is legally sufficient for sharing PHI with involved family members.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the client's cognitive status and current situation.
The client is competent (alert and oriented) but currently asleep, and this is not a medical emergency.
Determining competency dictates who has the legal right to authorize the release of protected health information.
2
Evaluate the adult child's legal access to the client's information.
The adult child is not a designated healthcare proxy and is not on the facility's disclosure form.
HIPAA requires explicit authorization to share information unless the client is present and does not object, or specific exceptions apply.
3
Determine the appropriate nursing intervention to maintain confidentiality while supporting family involvement.
The PN must wait until the client is awake to obtain direct verbal consent before sharing the list.
A competent client retains the right to control their health information, and direct consent must be obtained prior to disclosure.

Key Concept

Client Confidentiality and HIPAA Authorization Nuances
Rate this question