Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumEthical Practice

A community health clinic nurse assesses a 15-year-old who requests testing for a sexually transmitted infection. Upon physical examination, the nurse discovers multiple varying stages of bruising across the client's torso. The adolescent tearfully admits the injuries were inflicted by their primary caregiver but begs the nurse to keep it a secret. Which action is the most appropriate response by the nurse to uphold ethical and legal standards?

  1. A
    Promise to honor the request for secrecy in order to preserve the nurse-client relationship and foster trust.
  2. B
    Address the immediate physiological need by performing the infection screening first before considering psychosocial safety concerns.
  3. Gently explain to the client that the nursing staff is legally required to notify protective services regarding the injuries.Answer
  4. D
    Reassure the client by stating, 'Everything will be okay once we get your family the counseling they need.'

Answer

The correct action is to gently explain to the client that the nursing staff is legally required to notify protective services regarding the injuries.
The correct answer acknowledges the nurse's legal and ethical duty to report suspected abuse of a minor. While confidentiality is a core ethical principle, it is not absolute. Mandatory reporting laws require healthcare professionals to report suspected child abuse to protect the vulnerable client. The nurse must use veracity to honestly inform the client of this limit to confidentiality rather than going behind their back.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the ethical conflict presented in the scenario.
The nurse faces a conflict between maintaining client confidentiality (fidelity/autonomy) and protecting the client from harm (beneficence/nonmaleficence) through mandatory reporting.
Identifying the conflicting ethical principles is the first step in resolving a clinical dilemma.
2
Evaluate the legal limitations of confidentiality in this specific population.
The client is a minor (15 years old) experiencing physical abuse, which strictly falls under mandatory reporting laws.
Legal mandates, such as reporting suspected child or elder abuse, supersede the ethical duty to maintain confidentiality.
3
Determine the most therapeutic and ethical response.
The nurse must report the abuse to protective services while utilizing veracity (truth-telling) to inform the client of this necessary action.
Being truthful maintains respect for the client while ensuring their immediate safety and fulfilling strict legal obligations.

Key Concept

Limits of Confidentiality and Mandatory Reporting
Estimated Time:1m 15s
Rate this question

Topics

Ethical Practice

More questions from this topic