Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardEthical Practice

A nurse on a pediatric unit is assessing a 3-year-old child admitted with a spiral fracture of the humerus. The parents, who are prominent community figures, state the child simply tripped on a rug. The nurse observes that the child is profoundly withdrawn, flinches when approached, and has multiple fading bruises on the back and abdomen. The nurse privately expresses concerns about non-accidental trauma to the attending physician. The physician states, 'We lack definitive proof. Given their status in the community, filing a complaint right now could be disastrous for their family. We will just keep the child admitted for observation.' Which action demonstrates the nurse's appropriate ethical and legal response?

  1. A
    Document the physician's rationale in the medical record and maintain close observation of the family.
  2. B
    Question the parents separately to gather more conclusive evidence about how the fracture occurred.
  3. Contact the local child protective agency directly to file a report based on the clinical findings.Answer
  4. D
    Consult the hospital ethics committee to mediate the disagreement before taking further action.

Answer

The nurse must contact the local child protective agency directly to file a report based on the clinical findings.
Nurses are mandated by law to report suspected child abuse. The ethical principles of beneficence (doing good), nonmaleficence (preventing harm), and advocacy require the nurse to protect the vulnerable client. This independent duty supersedes the physician's instructions, the need for definitive proof, and any concerns regarding the family's socioeconomic status (which aligns with the principle of justice).

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the clinical findings and the client's history.
The combination of a spiral fracture, multiple fading bruises, and the child's withdrawn behavior strongly indicates non-accidental trauma (abuse).
Identifying the clinical red flags of abuse is the first step in protecting the vulnerable client.
2
Evaluate the physician's directive against legal and ethical standards.
The physician's request to delay reporting due to a lack of proof and the family's social status contradicts the nurse's independent legal obligation.
Nurses practice under their own licenses and must independently uphold the law and the American Nurses Association Code of Ethics.
3
Determine the required legal and ethical nursing action.
The nurse must directly report the suspected abuse to the appropriate state authorities immediately.
Mandatory reporting laws require reporting based on suspicion, not definitive proof, to ensure the immediate safety of the child.

Key Concept

Mandatory Reporting and Nurse Advocacy
Rate this question

Topics

Ethical Practice

More questions from this topic