Question

Difficulty: MediumEthical Practice

A client is admitted to the inpatient behavioral health unit with acute mania. The client begins pacing the hallway rapidly, shouting loudly, and kicking empty chairs, but has not physically threatened staff or other clients. An unlicensed assistive personnel (UAP) tells the registered nurse, 'This client is going to hurt someone. We should put them in restraints right now. I will go get the leather straps.' Based on the ethical principle of nonmaleficence and legal client rights, which action is most appropriate for the nurse to take?

  1. Intervene by utilizing verbal de-escalation techniques and offering the client a prescribed PRN antianxiety medication.Answer
  2. B
    Direct the UAP to apply the physical restraints while the nurse immediately contacts the healthcare provider for an emergency order.
  3. C
    Inform the client that physical restraints will be applied immediately if the destructive behavior continues.
  4. D
    Instruct the UAP to evaluate the client's emotional state to determine the underlying cause of the agitation.

Answer

The nurse must prioritize interventions that minimize restriction by first attempting verbal de-escalation and offering a prescribed PRN medication.
Clients in behavioral health settings retain their legal and ethical right to receive care in the least restrictive environment. The ethical principles of nonmaleficence (doing no harm) and respect for human dignity dictate that the nurse must prioritize interventions that minimize restriction while maintaining unit safety. Because the client has not physically harmed anyone, the nurse is ethically and legally required to first attempt less restrictive alternatives, such as verbal de-escalation, reducing environmental stimuli, or offering a prescribed PRN medication. Physical restraints are strictly a measure of last resort.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the client's behavior and the UAP's suggested intervention.
The client is highly agitated and disruptive but not currently a direct physical threat; the UAP is suggesting an immediate, highly restrictive intervention.
To determine the immediate safety needs of the milieu and evaluate the appropriateness of the proposed action.
2
Apply ethical and legal standards regarding psychiatric client rights.
The client has the legal right to the least restrictive environment. Nursing practice is guided by nonmaleficence (do no harm) and mandates avoiding unnecessary restraints.
Ethical practice requires balancing milieu safety with the individual client's autonomy and dignity.
3
Select the most appropriate nursing intervention.
The nurse must decline the UAP's suggestion and attempt less restrictive measures, such as verbal de-escalation and chemical restraint (PRN medication), before considering physical restraints.
This upholds the client's rights while safely addressing the escalating behavior in accordance with the ANA Code of Ethics.

Key Concept

Ethical Practice: Least Restrictive Environment
Rate this question