Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumEthical Practice

A nurse preceptor is guiding a newly licensed nurse in caring for a client with a terminal illness who is receiving palliative care. The client is grimacing, reports severe intractable pain, and requests their prescribed as-needed intravenous morphine. The client's current respiratory rate is 10 breaths/min. The newly licensed nurse states, "I must withhold the morphine because it could further depress their breathing and hasten death." Which of the following responses or actions by the preceptor are ethically and professionally appropriate? Select all that apply.

  1. Explain that the ethical principle of double effect justifies administering the medication when the primary intent is to relieve suffering.Answer
  2. Instruct the newly licensed nurse to administer the prescribed morphine to uphold the ethical duty of beneficence.Answer
  3. C
    Agree that the principle of nonmaleficence strictly requires withholding the dose to prevent respiratory depression.
  4. D
    Ask the client, "Why are you asking for more pain medication when your breathing is already so slow?"
  5. E
    Delegate the ongoing assessment of the client's respiratory status and pain relief to the unlicensed assistive personnel (UAP).
  6. Document the client's pain level, the administration of the medication, and the rationale for prioritizing comfort in the medical record.Answer

Answer

The ethically appropriate actions include explaining the Rule of Double Effect, administering the morphine to uphold beneficence, and accurately documenting the rationale for prioritizing comfort care.
In palliative and end-of-life care, the primary ethical obligation is beneficence, focusing on maximizing comfort and alleviating suffering. The Rule of Double Effect ethically supports the administration of necessary pain medications, such as opioids, even if they may cause unintended secondary effects like respiratory depression, provided the nurse's sole intent is to treat the pain. Additionally, documenting the clinical rationale ensures professional accountability and veracity.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the clinical scenario and the goals of care.
The client is terminally ill and receiving palliative care, where the primary goal is comfort and symptom management, not necessarily prolonging life.
Establishing the goals of care dictates which ethical principles take precedence in the decision-making process.
2
Evaluate the conflict between beneficence and nonmaleficence.
Administering morphine provides beneficence (pain relief) but poses a risk of nonmaleficence (respiratory depression).
Understanding this ethical conflict is essential for applying advanced ethical frameworks to resolve the dilemma.
3
Apply the ethical Rule of Double Effect.
The administration of the medication is justified because the nurse's primary and sole intent is to relieve the severe pain, even if respiratory depression is a foreseeable secondary effect.
This principle legally and ethically guides nurses providing aggressive symptom management at the end of life.
4
Identify appropriate delegation and communication standards.
Assessments cannot be delegated to UAP, and non-therapeutic communication blocks ('why' questions) must be avoided.
Ethical practice also requires maintaining professional standards of care and adhering strictly to the legal scope of practice.

Key Concept

Ethical Practice in Palliative Care: The Rule of Double Effect
Rate this question

Topics

Ethical Practice

More questions from this topic