Question

Difficulty: MediumEthical Practice

A home health nurse is evaluating an older adult client who has multiple unexplained bruises in various stages of healing. During the assessment, the client tearfully confides that their primary caregiver caused the injuries but begs the nurse not to tell anyone, expressing intense fear of being moved to a care facility. Which action by the nurse represents the most appropriate ethical and legal response?

  1. Report the suspected abuse to the designated state adult protective agency despite the client's request for secrecy.Answer
  2. B
    Honor the client's request for confidentiality to maintain trust and the therapeutic relationship.
  3. C
    Ask the client why the caregiver became violent to better understand the underlying family dynamics.
  4. D
    Focus solely on applying wound care to the bruises and assess for new injuries during the next scheduled visit.

Answer

The most appropriate action is to report the suspected abuse to the designated state adult protective agency despite the client's request for secrecy.
The correct action involves reporting the suspected abuse to the designated state agency. In nursing ethics, while confidentiality and autonomy are fundamental, they are not absolute. When a vulnerable adult is at risk of significant harm, the ethical duty of nonmaleficence and the legal mandate of mandatory reporting supersede the client's request for secrecy.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the conflict between ethical principles in the scenario.
The nurse faces a conflict between respecting the client's autonomy and confidentiality versus the duty of nonmaleficence (preventing harm).
Ethical dilemmas often require weighing competing principles to determine the priority action.
2
Apply legal frameworks regarding vulnerable populations.
Nurses are mandatory reporters for suspected elder abuse, which legally overrides confidentiality.
Legal statutes designed to protect vulnerable adults dictate that safety takes precedence over privacy in cases of abuse.
3
Determine the required nursing intervention.
The nurse must fulfill the legal and ethical obligation to report the suspected abuse to the appropriate authorities.
Failing to report suspected abuse places the client at risk for ongoing harm and violates the nurse's legal and ethical duties.

Key Concept

Limits of confidentiality and mandatory reporting of elder abuse
Estimated Time:1m 0s
Rate this question