Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumEthical Practice

A client voluntarily admitted to an inpatient psychiatric unit tells the nurse during a private conversation, "When I am discharged tomorrow, I am going to shoot my former boss. I have a weapon in my car, but you cannot tell anyone because what I say in here is confidential." Which of the following actions are ethically and legally appropriate for the nurse to take? (Select all that apply.)

  1. Document the exact statements made by the client and the observed behaviors in the medical record.Answer
  2. B
    Assure the client that their statements will remain strictly confidential to maintain therapeutic trust.
  3. Immediately notify the attending healthcare provider and nursing supervisor regarding the specific threat.Answer
  4. D
    Delay reporting the threat until the client signs a consent form releasing their protected health information.
  5. Initiate the facility's protocol for notifying potential victims and law enforcement.Answer
  6. F
    Prioritize conducting a thorough search of the client's belongings before informing the treatment team.

Answer

The nurse must prioritize public safety by breaching confidentiality when there is a specific, credible threat of harm to others (duty to warn). The correct actions are documenting the exact statements, immediately notifying the provider and supervisor, and following protocols to involve law enforcement.
The principle of confidentiality is a cornerstone of nursing practice, but it is not absolute. When a client makes a specific, credible threat of violence against an identifiable individual, the nurse has an ethical and legal obligation known as the 'duty to warn' (derived from the Tarasoff ruling). This requires the healthcare team to breach confidentiality to prevent imminent harm. Ethically appropriate actions include immediately notifying the healthcare provider and supervisor, initiating facility protocols to inform law enforcement, and maintaining objective documentation of the client's exact statements in the medical record.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the ethical conflict between the client's right to confidentiality and the ethical duty of nonmaleficence.
Identify that a specific, credible threat to an identifiable third party requires a justifiable breach of confidentiality.
The established legal and ethical 'duty to warn' mandates protecting potential victims from imminent danger.
2
Determine the appropriate immediate nursing interventions.
Notify the healthcare provider, nursing supervisor, and initiate protocols for warning law enforcement and the victim.
Collaborative communication ensures legal compliance and rapidly initiates protective measures outside the facility.
3
Ensure proper legal and clinical documentation.
Record the client's exact quotes and behaviors in the electronic health record.
Accurate documentation provides a factual, objective basis for the breach of confidentiality and subsequent legal actions.

Key Concept

Ethical Limits of Confidentiality and the Duty to Warn
Rate this question

Topics

Ethical Practice

More questions from this topic