Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Very hardEthical Practice

A nurse in the emergency department is caring for a 78-year-old client who presents with multiple bruises in various stages of healing, malnutrition, and a fractured radius. The client lives with their adult child, who is acting aggressively toward the staff and answering all questions for the client. The client is alert and oriented, but quietly states to the nurse, 'Please don't tell them, things will only get worse.' The adult child then demands to sign the client out Against Medical Advice (AMA). Which of the following ethical and legal actions should the nurse prioritize in this situation? Select all that apply.

  1. Inform the adult child that the alert and oriented client must personally sign the Against Medical Advice (AMA) form.Answer
  2. File a report with Adult Protective Services (APS) even though the client requested the information not be shared.Answer
  3. Utilize a facility protocol, such as a routine privacy policy for assessments, to separate the client from the adult child.Answer
  4. D
    Postpone contacting Adult Protective Services until conclusive evidence of physical abuse is established by the healthcare provider.
  5. E
    Promise the client that their statements about the living situation will be kept strictly confidential between the nurse and the client.
  6. F
    Focus initially on the physiological stabilization of the fracture, applying Maslow's hierarchy, before addressing the potential abuse.

Answer

The correct actions include informing the adult child that the client must sign the AMA form, reporting the abuse despite the client's request for secrecy, and utilizing facility protocols to separate the client from the abuser.
In cases of suspected elder abuse, mandatory reporting laws override the client's request for confidentiality, prioritizing the ethical principles of beneficence and nonmaleficence over autonomy. Because the client is alert and oriented, they retain the autonomy to make healthcare decisions and must be the one to sign any AMA documentation; the adult child has no legal authority to do so unless they are a designated proxy for an incapacitated client. Finally, separating the client from the suspected abuser using standard facility protocols ensures immediate physical safety and allows for a thorough assessment without unnecessarily escalating the conflict with the aggressive family member.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the legal constraints regarding Against Medical Advice (AMA) discharges.
The client is alert and oriented, meaning they retain decision-making capacity. The adult child cannot legally sign the AMA form on the client's behalf.
To protect client autonomy and prevent the unlawful removal of the client from the healthcare facility by an unauthorized third party.
2
Evaluate the ethical conflict between the client's request for confidentiality and the legal mandate to report elder abuse.
The nurse must report the suspected abuse to Adult Protective Services (APS).
Mandatory reporting laws for vulnerable populations supersede the ethical principle of confidentiality in order to uphold the principle of beneficence and prevent further harm.
3
Determine the safest method to assess the client and ensure their immediate protection.
The nurse should separate the client from the aggressive adult child using a non-confrontational approach, such as stating a facility policy requires private assessments.
Directly confronting the suspected abuser can escalate the situation, putting the client and staff at risk. Separating them allows for a safe, confidential assessment.

Key Concept

Ethical and legal responsibilities in suspected elder abuse, including mandatory reporting, limits of confidentiality, and client autonomy regarding AMA discharges.
Rate this question

Topics

Ethical Practice

More questions from this topic