Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardEthical Practice

During interdisciplinary rounds, healthcare teams must navigate complex situations involving client rights, professional duties, and moral obligations. Match each clinical scenario described on the left with the foundational ethical principle it most directly illustrates on the right.

  • Advocating for an undocumented, uninsured client to receive the same comprehensive discharge planning and home health resources as fully insured clients.Justice
  • Declining a provider's order to administer a dose of chemotherapy that significantly exceeds weight-based guidelines until the rationale is explicitly verified.Nonmaleficence
  • Remaining at the bedside to hold the hand of a dying client whose family has not yet arrived, fulfilling a previous commitment made to the client.Fidelity
  • Supporting a competent adult with a highly treatable infection who chooses to leave the facility against medical advice (AMA).Autonomy
  • Denying a family's request to conceal a terminal diagnosis from a competent client who has explicitly asked for their test results.Veracity

Answer

The correct matching aligns each scenario with its corresponding ethical principle: advocating for equal resources demonstrates justice, questioning an unsafe order demonstrates nonmaleficence, fulfilling a bedside promise demonstrates fidelity, supporting an AMA discharge demonstrates autonomy, and disclosing a terminal diagnosis demonstrates veracity.
Each clinical scenario corresponds precisely to a distinct ethical principle. Justice demands fairness in resource allocation. Nonmaleficence requires nurses to protect clients from harm. Fidelity mandates faithfulness to professional commitments. Autonomy requires respecting a competent client's right to direct their own care. Veracity dictates that nurses must be truthful with clients regarding their health status.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the scenario involving the uninsured client and discharge resources.
The nurse is ensuring equal access to care.
This identifies the application of fairness and equity in healthcare delivery, which defines justice.
2
Evaluate the scenario regarding the excessive chemotherapy order.
The nurse is actively preventing potential harm from an overdose.
This aligns with the duty to protect clients from injury or adverse effects, known as nonmaleficence.
3
Review the scenario about remaining at the bedside for a dying client.
The nurse is honoring a commitment made to a vulnerable client.
This reflects the obligation of loyalty and promise-keeping, which is fidelity.
4
Examine the scenario describing the client leaving against medical advice.
The nurse is respecting the client's self-determination.
Competent adults have the right to refuse care, demonstrating the principle of autonomy.
5
Assess the scenario concerning the terminal diagnosis disclosure.
The nurse is prioritizing honesty with the client over the family's wishes.
Clients have a right to truthful information about their own medical condition, representing veracity.

Key Concept

Core Ethical Principles in Nursing Practice
Rate this question

Topics

Ethical Practice

More questions from this topic