Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardLogical Inferences

In many mid-sized cities, municipal governments have converted central public parking lots into cargo distribution hubs to optimize local delivery logistics for digital retailers. Urban planner Clara Vance monitored pedestrian activity and business revenues in several such cities before and after the hub installations. Vance found that although local online delivery times decreased by 40%40\%, overall pedestrian foot traffic in the surrounding commercial districts fell by nearly 30%30\% due to the reduction in parking. Additionally, retail businesses in these districts that lacked online ordering options experienced a sharp decline in sales, while those that transitioned to delivery-based models maintained or increased their revenues. This suggests that _______

Which choice most logically completes the text?

  1. A
    the conversion of parking lots to cargo hubs failed to improve the efficiency of local business operations.
  2. B
    small businesses can only remain financially viable in mid-sized cities if they completely eliminate their physical storefronts.
  3. the decline in sales for physical-only retailers was likely driven by the decrease in district accessibility for physical visitors rather than a general reduction in consumer demand.Answer
  4. D
    the municipal governments' primary goal in converting the parking lots was to discourage residents from driving personal vehicles.

Answer

the decline in sales for physical-only retailers was likely driven by the decrease in district accessibility for physical visitors rather than a general reduction in consumer demand
The correct option logically completes the passage by explaining that because delivery-based retail models maintained or increased their revenues, local consumer demand for retail products remained stable. Therefore, the decline in sales for retailers lacking online options is best attributed to the drop in pedestrian traffic (accessibility) caused by the removal of parking space.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the key premises in the passage.
The conversion of parking lots to cargo hubs resulted in a 40%40\% decrease in local delivery times, but caused a 30%30\% drop in pedestrian foot traffic. Consequently, physical-only retailers suffered a decline in sales, whereas delivery-based retailers maintained or grew their sales.
Establishing the facts directly mentioned in the text is necessary to form a sound basis for inference.
2
Analyze the relationship between the premises.
Since businesses with delivery options succeeded while physical-only businesses failed, consumer demand for the products themselves was not the issue. The differentiating factor was how customers accessed the businesses (physically walking in vs. delivery).
Connecting the different outcomes of the two business models helps narrow down the cause of the decline.
3
Select the conclusion that logically follows without adding external assumptions.
The drop in sales for physical-only retailers was due to the lack of physical access/parking (foot traffic drop) rather than a loss of overall consumer demand.
This directly synthesizes the premises without introducing speculative claims.

Key Concept

Logical Inferences
Rate this question

Topics

Logical Inferences

More questions from this topic