Question

Difficulty: MediumCommand of Evidence: Textual

Historian Dr. Neil Clere and colleagues studied 14th-century maritime trade between East Africa and the Indian subcontinent. They hypothesized that while elite historical archives primarily highlight luxury goods like silk and porcelain, the bulk of the trade volume and economic activity actually consisted of mundane agricultural commodities like grain and timber, which left fewer traces in official customs records. Which finding, if true, would most directly support Clere and colleagues' hypothesis?

  1. Archaeological excavations of 14th-century port warehouses in East Africa revealed large quantities of storage jars containing residues of imported grains and fragments of non-native timber.Answer
  2. B
    Fourteenth-century customs records from major Indian Ocean ports detail the precise tariffs levied on imported silk, porcelain, and other elite commodities.
  3. C
    Diaries written by wealthy merchants in East Africa during the 14th century express a strong preference for purchasing local timber over importing wood from the Indian subcontinent.
  4. D
    Contemporary economic analyses of modern Indian Ocean trade show that agricultural goods now constitute a much higher percentage of total trade value than luxury items do.

Answer

The finding that archaeological excavations of 14th-century port warehouses in East Africa revealed large quantities of storage jars containing residues of imported grains and fragments of non-native timber.
The correct answer provides physical evidence of the import and storage of grain and timber in 14th-century East African ports. Since the researchers hypothesized that these mundane goods were traded in large volumes but omitted from written records, finding physical remains of these goods directly supports their claim.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the researchers' hypothesis in the passage.
The hypothesis is that the majority of 14th-century maritime trade between East Africa and the Indian subcontinent consisted of mundane goods like grain and timber, which are underrepresented in elite written archives.
Understanding the specific claim is necessary to evaluate which finding supports it.
2
Evaluate the choices to find evidence of high-volume trade in mundane agricultural commodities.
The finding regarding archaeological evidence of imported grains and non-native timber in East African port warehouses directly substantiates the existence of this trade.
Physical archaeological evidence of these specific goods fills the gap left by the lack of written records.
3
Verify that other options do not support the hypothesis.
Confirming the focus on luxury goods in customs records merely restates the background problem, suggesting local sourcing of timber contradicts the import hypothesis, and modern trade patterns are irrelevant to the 14th century.
Ensures that the selected option is uniquely correct and directly addresses the prompt's logical constraint.

Key Concept

Identifying textual evidence that directly supports a specific research hypothesis.
Rate this question