Question

Difficulty: HardCommand of Evidence: Textual

In his study of Mesoamerican agricultural history, environmental historian Dr. Aris Thorne investigated the response of ancient Maya communities to the volcanic eruption of Tierra Blanca Joven in the sixth century CE. While some scholars argue that the widespread deposition of volcanic ash led to a catastrophic decline in agricultural productivity that forced communities to abandon their settlements, Thorne contends that many Maya farmers adapted successfully. He argues that rather than abandoning their fields, these farmers mitigated the impacts of soil acidification and atmospheric cooling by shifting their primary cultivation from maize to root crops, which are more resilient to such environmental stresses.

Which finding, if true, would most directly support Thorne's argument?

  1. A
    Chemical analysis of soil layers from the region reveals that the acidity levels returned to pre-eruption baselines within two decades of the volcanic event.
  2. Excavations of domestic middens from the post-eruption period show a marked decrease in maize residue alongside a high concentration of starch residues from sweet potato and cassava plants.Answer
  3. C
    Historical accounts from neighboring regions suggest that trade in wild tubers increased significantly across Mesoamerica during the sixth century CE.
  4. D
    Pollen records indicate that the overall diversity of plant species in Mesoamerican forests declined sharply following the eruption.

Answer

Excavations of domestic middens from the post-eruption period show a marked decrease in maize residue alongside a high concentration of starch residues from sweet potato and cassava plants.
The correct answer is the option that reports a decrease in maize residue combined with a high concentration of root crop starch residues in post-eruption refuse. This provides direct physical evidence that the diet, and by extension the farming practices, shifted away from maize to sweet potatoes and cassava after the eruption, validating the historian's claim.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the author's primary claim in the passage.
Dr. Aris Thorne argues that Maya farmers adapted to post-eruption environmental challenges by shifting their primary cultivation from maize to root crops (such as sweet potatoes and cassava).
Understanding the precise claim to be supported is the first step in resolving textual evidence questions.
2
Evaluate the choices to see which one provides direct evidence of this crop shift.
The option noting a decrease in maize residue and an increase in sweet potato and cassava starch residues in household garbage (middens) directly shows that consumption, and therefore cultivation, shifted as predicted.
Direct archaeological indicators of domestic consumption changes are highly reliable for testing agricultural changes.
3
Analyze and eliminate the distractors.
Eliminated options that address general soil recovery, trade in wild plants in neighboring regions, or general forest decline, as none of these establish the localized crop transition claim.
Distractors often mention relevant themes (like tubers or soil conditions) but support unrelated claims or require speculative leaps.

Key Concept

Identifying textual evidence that directly supports a specific research hypothesis.
Rate this question