Question

Difficulty: MediumLogical Inferences

Urban heat islands, characterized by elevated temperatures in city centers compared to rural surroundings, have been shown to accelerate the phenology of many plant species, causing them to leaf out earlier in the spring. However, researcher Elena Vance and colleagues observed that urban populations of the cherry plum (*Prunus cerasifera*) did not leaf out earlier than rural populations, despite experiencing warmer spring temperatures. Vance hypothesized that this anomaly occurs because *P. cerasifera* requires a minimum threshold of winter chilling to break bud dormancy. Because milder urban winters delay the completion of this chilling requirement, which choice most logically completes the text?

  1. A
    urban cherry plums are eventually expected to adapt to milder winters by entirely eliminating their requirement for winter chilling.
  2. the delay in breaking dormancy offsets the accelerating effect that warmer spring temperatures have on the trees' development.Answer
  3. C
    the overall health and reproductive success of rural cherry plums are significantly greater than those of urban populations.
  4. D
    warmer spring temperatures in urban areas are actually less effective at promoting leaf-out than spring temperatures in rural areas are.

Answer

the delay in breaking dormancy offsets the accelerating effect that warmer spring temperatures have on the trees' development.
The correct option identifies the logical interaction between the two temperature-dependent processes described in the text: spring warming and winter chilling. Since winter chilling must happen before dormancy is broken, a delay in chilling delays the release of dormancy. This delayed dormancy release counteracts (offsets) the acceleration that warmer spring temperatures would otherwise cause, logically explaining why the urban cherry plums did not leaf out earlier.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the primary phenomenon and the anomaly presented in the text.
Typically, warmer temperatures cause plants to leaf out earlier, but urban cherry plums do not show this advancement despite warmer urban temperatures.
Establishing the central contradiction that the correct inference must resolve.
2
Analyze the biological mechanism proposed to explain the anomaly.
Cherry plums need winter chilling to break dormancy. Milder urban winters delay the completion of this chilling, meaning dormancy is broken later in the year.
Connecting the temperature conditions to the physiological state of the plants.
3
Synthesize the two opposing factors to determine the net outcome.
The delay in breaking dormancy acts as a decelerator, which cancels out the accelerating effect of the warmer spring temperatures.
Concluding the logical sequence to complete the final sentence of the text.

Key Concept

Logical Inferences
Rate this question