Question

Difficulty: HardOverall Text Structure Analysis

For centuries, historians assumed that the elaborate agricultural terraces of the pre-Inca Wari Empire were constructed primarily to maximize arable land in the steep Andean terrain. However, archaeologist Ann Peters has recently challenged this view, arguing that the terraces' main function was microclimate regulation to prevent crop frost. Peters analyzed soil temperature differentials across reconstructed terracing systems, demonstrating that the stone retaining walls retained daytime heat and gradually released it during freezing nights. While some scholars remain skeptical of Peters's singular focus, her research has shifted the academic conversation toward viewing terracing as a sophisticated form of thermal engineering rather than a simple response to spatial limitations.

Which choice best describes the overall structure of the text?

  1. It outlines a long-held explanation for a historical practice, presents an alternative hypothesis regarding that practice's function, details the research supporting this new view, and assesses the impact of this research on the academic community.Answer
  2. B
    It introduces a controversy regarding an ancient empire's agricultural expansion, evaluates two competing methods for reconstructing historical terraces, and advocates for a synthesis of both techniques.
  3. C
    It describes the physical properties of stone retaining walls, details how these walls absorb and release heat, and concludes that thermal regulation is the primary driver of agricultural productivity in high-altitude environments.
  4. D
    It defends a traditional archaeological theory against recent criticism, highlights the flaws in a study about soil temperature differentials, and calls for more rigorous data collection.

Answer

It outlines a long-held explanation for a historical practice, presents an alternative hypothesis regarding that practice's function, details the research supporting this new view, and assesses the impact of this research on the academic community.
The correct answer accurately reflects the sequence of rhetorical moves in the text. The passage starts by identifying a traditional belief about Wari terracing (space maximization), transitions to a counterhypothesis proposed by Peters (frost prevention via thermal regulation), explains her research methodology and findings regarding heat release, and closes by discussing how her work has changed scholarly perspectives despite some remaining skepticism.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the opening sentence of the passage to identify the initial premise.
The passage begins by describing the long-held historical assumption that Wari agricultural terraces were built primarily to maximize arable space.
This establishes the traditional explanation that serves as the starting point of the text.
2
Identify the transition and the introduction of the alternative perspective.
The word 'However' introduces Peters's new hypothesis: that the terraces primarily functioned to regulate microclimates and prevent frost.
This marks the shift from the traditional explanation to the new, competing theory.
3
Determine the role of the next sentence, which details Peters's methodology.
The text details Peters's study of soil temperature differentials in reconstructed terraces to show how the stone walls release heat.
This serves as the empirical evidence supporting the alternative hypothesis.
4
Evaluate the concluding sentence and the overall movement of the text.
The final sentence discusses the academic reaction (some skepticism) and the broader consequence of her work (shifting the academic conversation).
This shows how the text concludes by assessing the scientific impact of the new hypothesis.

Key Concept

Overall Text Structure Analysis
Rate this question