Examkin

Question

Difficulty: EasyRhetorical Synthesis: Comparison and Contrast

While researching ancient Mediterranean merchant ships, a student took the following notes:

* The *Kyrenia* shipwreck represents a Greek merchant vessel that sank in the 4th century BCE.
* The *Kyrenia* vessel was relatively small, measuring approximately 14 meters in length.
* The *Madrague de Giens* shipwreck represents a Roman merchant vessel that sank around 75–60 BCE.
* The *Madrague de Giens* vessel was a large cargo ship, measuring approximately 40 meters in length.

The student wants to contrast the lengths of the two vessels. Which choice most effectively uses information from the given notes to accomplish this goal?

  1. A
    The Greek vessel *Kyrenia* sank in the 4th century BCE, whereas the Roman vessel *Madrague de Giens* sank in the 1st century BCE.
  2. While the Greek merchant vessel *Kyrenia* was only about 14 meters long, the Roman freighter *Madrague de Giens* measured approximately 40 meters in length.Answer
  3. C
    The Roman ship *Madrague de Giens* and the Greek ship *Kyrenia* were both large merchant vessels measuring exactly 40 meters in length.
  4. D
    Measuring approximately 14 meters in length, the Greek merchant vessel *Kyrenia* was constructed primarily to carry cargo across the Mediterranean.

Answer

While the Greek merchant vessel *Kyrenia* was only about 14 meters long, the Roman freighter *Madrague de Giens* measured approximately 40 meters in length.
The correct choice effectively contrasts the lengths of the two vessels by stating that the Greek vessel *Kyrenia* was about 14 meters long while the Roman freighter *Madrague de Giens* was approximately 40 meters long. This directly uses the factual information from the notes to achieve the desired rhetorical goal.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the rhetorical goal stated in the prompt.
The goal is to contrast the lengths of the two merchant vessels (*Kyrenia* and *Madrague de Giens*).
Understanding the exact objective helps eliminate choices that focus on other details, such as age or cargo type.
2
Retrieve the relevant length measurements from the notes for both vessels.
The *Kyrenia* is approximately 14 meters long, and the *Madrague de Giens* is approximately 40 meters long.
The correct option must contain these accurate metrics to make a valid comparison.
3
Evaluate the choices to find the one that contrasts these two specific measurements in a single, grammatically complete sentence.
The statement that describes the *Kyrenia* as about 14 meters long and the *Madrague de Giens* as approximately 40 meters long is the only one that fulfills this goal.
This sentence directly compares the sizes of the two vessels while remaining factually accurate to the notes.

Key Concept

Synthesizing details from a list of notes to construct a sentence that contrasts specific features of two entities.
Rate this question

Topics

Rhetorical Synthesis: Comparison and Contrast

More questions from this topic