Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumUnion Executive: President, Vice-President, PM, and Council of Ministers

The President of India generally acts on the aid and advice of the Union Council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister. However, the Constitution permits the exercise of situational discretion under specific conditions. In which of the following scenarios is the President empowered to exercise situational discretion without relying on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers?

  1. Appointment of the Prime Minister when no single political party or coalition commands a clear majority in the Lok SabhaAnswer
  2. B
    Promulgation of an executive ordinance during the recess of Parliament under Article 123
  3. C
    Granting pardon or commuting a sentence imposed by a Court Martial under Article 72
  4. D
    Proclaiming a National Emergency under Article 352 on the grounds of armed rebellion

Answer

The appointment of the Prime Minister when no single political party or coalition commands a clear majority in the Lok Sabha represents a situation where the President exercises situational discretion.
The President of India possesses situational discretion (discretion arising out of parliamentary circumstances) in appointing the Prime Minister when no political party or pre-poll alliance commands an absolute majority in the Lok Sabha.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Examine the constitutional framework governing aid and advice under Article 74.
Article 74(1) mandates that the President shall act in accordance with the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister in executing executive duties.
India follows a parliamentary system of government where real executive authority resides in the cabinet.
2
Identify recognized instances of situational discretion vested in the President.
When no party holds a majority after a general election, or when a Prime Minister dies in office without an obvious successor, the President must use personal judgement to appoint a Prime Minister under Article 75(1).
An outgoing or non-existent council of ministers cannot render binding advice on who should form the next government when the parliamentary mandate is indecisive.
3
Evaluate the constitutional restrictions on other executive and legislative functions.
Ordinance promulgation (Article 123), clemency decisions (Article 72), and emergency declarations (Article 352) strictly require Council of Ministers or Cabinet recommendation.
The Supreme Court has consistently held (e.g., Shamsher Singh case, 1974) that constitutional satisfaction of the President means the satisfaction of the Council of Ministers.

Key Concept

Situational Discretion of the President of India
Rate this question

Topics

Union Executive: President, Vice-President, PM, and Council of Ministers

More questions from this topic