Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumCourse of Action

Statement: A sudden outbreak of a highly contagious water-borne disease has been reported in a densely populated suburban district, and health officials have traced the primary source to severe contamination within the municipal water supply lines.

Proposed Course of Action: The local municipal administration should immediately permanently seal off and concrete over all water lines in the district, mandating that residents exclusively purchase their daily water from private vendors indefinitely.

This proposed course of action represents a logically sound and practical administrative remedy.

Answer: Answer

Answer

False
The proposed course of action is false because it represents an extreme, disproportionate, and impractical administrative response. Instead of identifying and fixing the contamination in the municipal supply, the action proposes permanently abandoning public infrastructure and imposing a massive financial burden on residents. Sound administrative logic dictates that temporary relief should be provided while the root cause is repaired.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the core problem presented in the statement.
The problem is a public health crisis triggered by contaminated municipal water supply lines in a specific district.
Understanding the exact nature and scope of the problem is necessary to evaluate the appropriateness of any proposed remedy.
2
Evaluate the proposed course of action against the criteria of feasibility, proportionality, and problem resolution.
The proposed action suggests permanently destroying the existing public water infrastructure and shifting the entire burden of water procurement to the residents via private vendors.
A valid course of action must solve the problem without creating a worse administrative, economic, or humanitarian crisis.
3
Determine the logical validity of the course of action.
The action is logically invalid. It is an extreme, reactionary measure that fails to rectify the actual contamination issue and severely harms the public interest.
Administrative decisions must be corrective, proportional, and aim to restore essential public functionality.

Key Concept

Evaluating Administrative Feasibility and Proportionality in Decision Making
Estimated Time:45s
Rate this question

Topics

Course of Action

More questions from this topic