Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumCourse of Action

Problem: A routine performance review of a state-run healthcare initiative discovered that 15% of the allocated quarterly funds were misdirected due to data entry mistakes made by temporary staff during the digitization of patient records.
Proposed Course of Action: The health department should immediately deduct the misdirected funds directly from the salaries of the temporary staff to recover the financial loss.

Determine if the following statement is true or false: The proposed course of action is logically sound and represents a practical administrative remedy.

Answer: Answer

Answer

False
The proposed course of action is invalid because deducting misdirected scheme funds from the salaries of temporary staff for unintentional clerical errors is an extreme and disproportionate measure. Furthermore, it fails to address the root cause, which is a lack of systemic data verification.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the problem stem to identify the core issue and its cause.
The problem is a systemic financial misdirection caused by unintentional data entry errors made by temporary personnel, rather than intentional fraud.
Identifying the nature of the root cause is crucial for determining the appropriate administrative response.
2
Evaluate the proposed course of action for proportionality and feasibility.
Deducting government scheme funds from the salaries of temporary staff is highly disproportionate to a clerical mistake and is likely legally unfeasible.
A valid administrative course of action must be fair, legally viable, and not introduce disproportionate harm.
3
Determine if the proposed action addresses the systemic root cause of the problem.
The proposed action focuses purely on punitive financial recovery and fails to implement data validation protocols or training to prevent future mistakes.
Effective courses of action must implement sustainable corrections to prevent the problem from recurring.

Key Concept

Evaluating the proportionality, legality, and root-cause effectiveness of an administrative course of action.
Rate this question

Topics

Course of Action

More questions from this topic