Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Very hardUnion Legislature: Parliament Structure, Lawmaking, and Committees

Match the following Parliamentary Motions and Devices of the Indian Parliament in List-I with their specific procedural characteristics or legal requirements in List-II:

  • Adjournment MotionRequires support of at least 50 members for admission, interrupts normal proceedings, and involves an element of censure against the government.
  • Calling Attention MotionAn Indian parliamentary innovation that seeks an official statement from a Minister on a matter of urgent public importance without interrupting normal business.
  • Privilege MotionMoved against a Minister when a member feels that facts have been withheld or distorted, thereby breaching the sanctity of legislative proceedings.
  • Censure MotionMust state specific grounds or policy failures, can target individual ministers or the entire cabinet, but does not obligate immediate ministry resignation.

Answer

The correct matches pair Adjournment Motion with requiring 50 members' support to discuss an urgent matter while carrying censure, Calling Attention Motion with seeking a Minister's statement on urgent public importance without interrupting business, Privilege Motion with addressing a breach caused by withholding or distorting facts, and Censure Motion with stating specific charges against ministers without mandating immediate cabinet resignation upon passage.
Adjournment Motion involves an emergency interruption requiring 50 members' support and implies censure. Calling Attention Motion is an Indian parliamentary innovation seeking an official ministerial statement. Privilege Motion holds ministers accountable for misleading the House or withholding facts. Censure Motion requires explicit grounds and can target specific ministers or the entire cabinet without automatically collapsing the government.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the procedural threshold and nature of an Adjournment Motion.
It requires the support of at least 50 members for leave to be granted, interrupts standard business, and implies censure of government conduct.
It is an extraordinary motion reserved exclusively for urgent matters of immediate concern in Lok Sabha.
2
Identify the distinct origin and purpose of a Calling Attention Motion.
It is an Indian parliamentary creation introduced in 1954 to elicit an official ministerial statement without suspending regular proceedings.
It allows members to highlight urgent public matters formally within rules of procedure.
3
Determine the legal grounds for moving a Privilege Motion.
It is moved when a Minister gives wrong or distorted information or suppresses facts, breaching parliamentary privilege.
Ensures executive accountability regarding accurate communication to the legislature.
4
Evaluate the conditions and consequences of a Censure Motion.
It must state specific reasons/charges and can target individual ministers or the cabinet as a whole; passing it does not force cabinet resignation, unlike a No-Confidence Motion.
Censure is meant to reprimand specific policies or actions, whereas No-Confidence tests overall majority support.

Key Concept

Parliamentary Devices and Legislative Motions in the Indian Parliament
Rate this question

Topics

Union Legislature: Parliament Structure, Lawmaking, and Committees

More questions from this topic