Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Very hardBarriers to Effective Communication

During a multi-agency municipal coordination conference on urban flood management, a Chief Engineer presents a technical hydrologic model using dense statistical terminology and obscure fluid-dynamics acronyms to field officers. Simultaneously, several field officers, fearing reprimand for previous operational delays, selectively withhold critical ground-level data regarding drain blockages. Which of the following correctly classifies the primary communication barriers exhibited by the Chief Engineer and the field officers, respectively?

  1. The Chief Engineer exhibited a semantic barrier through specialized technical jargon, whereas the field officers demonstrated an organizational and psychological barrier by filtering information out of evaluation apprehension.Answer
  2. B
    The Chief Engineer created an environmental noise barrier by presenting complex statistical models, whereas the field officers exhibited a kinesic barrier by withholding verbal reports.
  3. C
    The Chief Engineer demonstrated a paralinguistic barrier through complex presentation pitch, whereas the field officers displayed a kinesic barrier through silent body language during the meeting.
  4. D
    The Chief Engineer manifested an aggressive communication barrier by imposing dense technical acronyms, whereas the field officers maintained an assertive communication barrier to safeguard operational autonomy.

Answer

The Chief Engineer exhibited a semantic barrier through specialized technical jargon, whereas the field officers demonstrated an organizational and psychological barrier by filtering information out of evaluation apprehension.
The correct option accurately identifies the dual barriers in the scenario: the Chief Engineer's usage of complex, technical jargon forms a classic semantic barrier because message decoding fails due to vocabulary mismatches; meanwhile, the field officers' deliberate withholding of uncomfortable facts to prevent negative evaluation constitutes organizational filtering driven by psychological apprehension.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the Chief Engineer's communication behavior.
The Chief Engineer uses dense statistical terminology and fluid-dynamics acronyms unfamiliar to field officers.
When communication fails because the sender uses specialized, obscure, or overly complex language and symbols that the receiver cannot decode properly, it is categorized as a semantic barrier.
2
Analyze the field officers' communication behavior.
The field officers selectively suppress and manipulate ground-level facts to avoid punishment for operational delays.
When information is manipulated or withheld as it flows through organizational channels due to fear of authority or performance appraisal anxiety, it constitutes organizational filtering combined with a psychological defense mechanism.
3
Synthesize and match both behaviors to their formal interpersonal communication classifications.
Chief Engineer = Semantic Barrier; Field Officers = Organizational / Psychological Filtering Barrier.
Matching both components confirms that the Chief Engineer created a semantic barrier and the officers created an organizational filtering barrier.

Key Concept

Classification of Semantic, Psychological, and Organizational Barriers to Communication
Rate this question

Topics

Barriers to Effective Communication

More questions from this topic