Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumPatient-Physician Relationship and Boundaries

A 45-year-old physician is attending a weekend family reunion. During the event, the physician's 40-year-old brother privately mentions that he has been experiencing severe anxiety and insomnia due to an impending divorce and fear of losing his job. He states his primary care provider is fully booked for the next six weeks. He asks the physician to call in a 30-day prescription for lorazepam to his local pharmacy to 'help him get through this rough patch.' The brother does not have any active suicidal ideation or symptoms of psychosis. Which of the following is the most appropriate verbal response by the physician?

  1. I cannot prescribe this medication for you, as professional guidelines advise against treating immediate family members outside of an emergency.Answer
  2. B
    I can provide a one-week emergency supply to bridge you, provided you schedule a formal clinic visit with me on Monday.
  3. C
    Since you demonstrate clear decision-making capacity regarding the risks of this medication, I can authorize the prescription.
  4. D
    I am unable to prescribe this for you, and given your level of distress, I am required to report your situation to adult protective services.
  5. E
    I cannot prescribe a controlled substance like lorazepam for you, but I can prescribe a non-controlled medication for anxiety.

Answer

The physician should state that they cannot prescribe the medication because professional guidelines advise against treating immediate family members outside of an emergency.
Physicians should generally not treat themselves or members of their immediate families, as their medical judgment can be compromised by emotional involvement. Exceptions exist only for true emergencies or minor, short-term illnesses when no other qualified physician is available. The patient's condition (anxiety and insomnia) is not a medical emergency, and prescribing a psychotropic medication, especially a controlled substance like lorazepam, is a severe boundary violation. The physician must politely decline the request and advise the brother to seek care from an independent healthcare professional, such as through an urgent care center or walk-in clinic if he cannot wait for his primary care provider.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the core ethical dilemma in the scenario.
The physician is asked by an immediate family member (brother) to prescribe a psychotropic medication for anxiety and insomnia.
Understanding the relationship between the physician and the patient is crucial for applying boundary guidelines.
2
Recall the ethical guidelines regarding treating family members.
Physicians should generally not treat themselves or their immediate family members, except in emergencies or for minor, short-term issues when another physician is unavailable.
Emotional involvement compromises objective medical judgment and informed consent.
3
Evaluate the specific clinical request against the exceptions.
The request is for a controlled psychotropic medication (lorazepam) for a non-emergent condition (anxiety/insomnia), which does not qualify for an exception.
Prescribing psychotropics to family members is explicitly advised against due to the high risk of dependence and lack of objective monitoring.
4
Determine the most appropriate professional response.
The physician must politely refuse the prescription request and explain that professional guidelines prohibit this boundary crossing.
Clear communication sets appropriate boundaries while educating the family member on ethical constraints.

Key Concept

Patient-Physician Boundaries (Treating Family Members)
Rate this question

Topics

Patient-Physician Relationship and Boundaries

More questions from this topic