Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumPatient-Physician Relationship and Boundaries

A 42-year-old family physician is the medical director of a busy outpatient practice. At the end of the workday, the clinic's 38-year-old office manager approaches him in his private office. She states that she has been experiencing severe stress, palpitations, and difficulty sleeping over the past month due to a sudden illness in her family. She asks if he could write a quick prescription for a short course of an anxiolytic medication, explaining that her regular primary care provider has no available appointments for the next three weeks and she is struggling to function at work. She has no known past medical history and is not an established patient at the practice. Which of the following is the most appropriate response by the physician?

  1. Decline the request and recommend that she seek evaluation at an urgent care center or with another clinicianAnswer
  2. B
    Prescribe a one-week supply of the requested medication to provide relief until her scheduled appointment
  3. C
    Perform a focused evaluation in the office and prescribe the medication only if no clinical contraindications are identified
  4. D
    Agree to prescribe the medication under the condition that she officially registers as a patient at the practice
  5. E
    Provide the prescription but require her to sign a waiver acknowledging the informal nature of the medical advice

Answer

Decline the request and recommend that she seek evaluation at an urgent care center or with another clinician.
Physicians should generally avoid providing medical care to themselves, immediate family members, and employees. Treating an employee creates a dual relationship characterized by a significant power imbalance. This dynamic can compromise the physician's medical objectivity and make it difficult for the employee to provide fully voluntary informed consent, refuse unwanted medical advice, or disclose sensitive information. Prescribing psychotropic medications (like anxiolytics) outside of a formal, independent patient-physician relationship is particularly discouraged. Because the employee is not experiencing a true life-threatening medical emergency, the most appropriate action is to politely decline the request and direct her to an independent healthcare provider, such as an urgent care clinic.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the nature of the relationship between the physician and the individual requesting care.
The individual is the physician's office manager (an employee/subordinate).
Recognizing the preexisting relationship is crucial for identifying potential ethical conflicts.
2
Evaluate the ethical implications of the requested action.
The employee is asking for a prescription for an anxiolytic, which involves psychotropic medication and establishes a physician-patient relationship.
Prescribing medication requires a formal, objective clinical assessment.
3
Apply ethical guidelines regarding boundaries and dual relationships.
Determine that treating an employee creates a problematic dual relationship due to the inherent power imbalance, compromising objectivity and the employee's ability to freely consent or refuse care.
Professional guidelines (e.g., AMA Code of Medical Ethics) strongly discourage treating employees.
4
Select the most appropriate course of action.
The physician must decline to prescribe the medication and direct the employee to seek care from an independent provider.
This maintains professional boundaries and ensures the employee receives objective medical care.

Key Concept

Dual relationships and boundaries when considering treating employees or subordinates.
Rate this question

Topics

Patient-Physician Relationship and Boundaries

More questions from this topic