Question

Difficulty: MediumMeasures of Association and Impact

Match each clinical or epidemiological scenario to the most appropriate statistical measure of association or impact that should be calculated.

  • A physician wants to communicate the practical clinical benefit of a new migraine prophylaxis medication by expressing exactly how many patients must receive the drug to prevent one attack.Number needed to treat (NNT)
  • Researchers conducting a case-control study need to report the statistical association between maternal use of a specific anticonvulsant and the occurrence of a rare neural tube defect.Odds ratio (OR)
  • An epidemiologist wishes to determine the absolute excess incidence of stroke that is directly attributable to uncontrolled hypertension within a specific cohort of adult patients.Attributable risk (AR)
  • A public health department aims to estimate the proportion of all lung cancer cases in their jurisdiction that could theoretically be eliminated if tobacco smoking were completely eradicated.Population attributable risk percent (PAR%)

Answer

The correct matches are: 1) Clinical benefit communication matches with Number needed to treat (NNT); 2) Case-control study matches with Odds ratio (OR); 3) Absolute excess incidence matches with Attributable risk (AR); 4) Proportion of all cases in a population matches with Population attributable risk percent (PAR%).
Each scenario specifically describes the defining characteristic of a different biostatistical measure. NNT is uniquely suited for translating absolute risk reduction into a tangible number for clinical practice. OR is the mathematically required measure of association for case-control studies. AR isolates the excess risk within an exposed group, while PAR% scales that risk to demonstrate public health impact across an entire population.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the first scenario regarding communicating practical clinical benefit to a patient.
Identify that expressing how many patients must be treated to prevent one event defines the Number Needed to Treat (NNT).
NNT is derived from the absolute risk reduction and translates statistical findings into concrete clinical terms for shared decision-making.
2
Analyze the second scenario involving a case-control study of a rare disease.
Identify that the Odds Ratio (OR) is the required measure.
Case-control studies cannot calculate relative risk (RR) because they do not track incidence over time; they must use the OR to estimate the association.
3
Analyze the third scenario regarding the absolute excess incidence in an exposed cohort.
Identify that Attributable Risk (AR) is the appropriate calculation.
AR directly subtracts the baseline risk of the unexposed from the total risk of the exposed to find the excess risk caused by the exposure.
4
Analyze the fourth scenario focusing on the proportion of total cases in a jurisdiction that could be eliminated.
Identify that Population Attributable Risk Percent (PAR%) is the correct metric.
Unlike AR, which focuses only on the exposed cohort, PAR% scales the impact to the entire population by incorporating the prevalence of the exposure.

Key Concept

Selection of appropriate measures of association and impact based on study design and clinical or public health objectives.
Rate this question