Question

Difficulty: MediumMeasures of Association and Impact

Match each clinical research scenario or statistical objective to the most appropriate measure of association or impact used to quantify it.

  • Investigators recruit hospitalized patients with severe acute pancreatitis and compare their history of thiazide diuretic use to that of patients admitted for non-pancreatic conditions.Odds Ratio (OR)
  • A cardiovascular trial utilizes a Kaplan-Meier estimator to report the relative likelihood of a myocardial infarction occurring at any precise moment among patients on a novel antiplatelet drug versus standard therapy.Hazard Ratio (HR)
  • Researchers studying a cohort of industrial miners calculate the specific fraction of chronic beryllium disease cases that would theoretically not have occurred if the miners had never been exposed to beryllium dust.Attributable Risk Percent (ARP)
  • A clinical trial demonstrates that an experimental weight-loss medication increases the absolute risk of cholelithiasis by 4%4\%. Clinicians calculate how many patients must be prescribed the drug to expect one extra case of gallstones.Number Needed to Harm (NNH)

Answer

The scenarios correctly match to: Case-control study with Odds Ratio (OR), Survival analysis with Hazard Ratio (HR), Proportion of disease due to exposure with Attributable Risk Percent (ARP), and Patient count for one adverse event with Number Needed to Harm (NNH).
Each statistical measure serves a highly specific epidemiological function. Case-control studies necessitate the use of an Odds Ratio because incidence cannot be directly measured. Survival analyses utilize Hazard Ratios to compare instantaneous event rates over a continuum of time. Attributable Risk Percent isolates the proportion of disease incidence directly resulting from a specific exposure. Finally, the Number Needed to Harm translates absolute risk increases into a clinically actionable patient count.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the pancreatitis study design.
Identified as a case-control study (comparing diseased patients to non-diseased controls based on past exposure).
Case-control studies require the Odds Ratio because true disease incidence rates are unknown.
2
Evaluate the cardiovascular trial using Kaplan-Meier estimators.
Identified as a time-to-event survival analysis.
Hazard Ratios uniquely measure the instantaneous relative risk over time, accounting for censored patient data in survival analysis.
3
Determine the metric for the fraction of disease due to beryllium.
Identified as the proportion of incidence attributable to the exposure.
Attributable Risk Percent (ARP=RR−1RRARP = \frac{RR - 1}{RR}) calculates the exact percentage of disease cases in the exposed group that are directly caused by the exposure.
4
Calculate the metric associated with a 4%4\% absolute risk increase for gallstones.
Identified as the Number Needed to Harm.
The question asks for the number of patients treated to cause one adverse event, calculated as NNH=1Absolute Risk IncreaseNNH = \frac{1}{\text{Absolute Risk Increase}}.

Key Concept

Selection of epidemiological metrics based on specific study designs and clinical objectives.
Rate this question