Soru

Zorluk: OrtaRelationships Between Sections and Paragraphs

The following passage is adapted from an essay on the history of geology.

Paragraph 1
In the late eighteenth century, the prevailing scientific consensus in Europe held that the Earth was only a few thousand years old, a view primarily derived from biblical chronology. Most geological features were explained by "catastrophism"—the theory that Earth’s landscape had been shaped rapidly by sudden, short-lived, worldwide disasters. For instance, mountains and valleys were believed to be the remnants of Noah’s flood. This framework left little room for gradual processes, framing geological history as a series of abrupt, dramatic interventions.

Paragraph 2
James Hutton, a Scottish physician and naturalist, proposed a radically different view known as uniformitarianism. He argued that the geological forces shaping the Earth today—such as erosion, sedimentation, and volcanic activity—have operated at the same slow rate throughout the planet's history. To prove this theory, however, Hutton needed physical evidence of what he called "unconformities": points in the rock record where older, tilted layers of rock were overlaid by younger, horizontal layers, representing a vast gap in geological time during which erosion occurred before new rock deposited.

Paragraph 3
Hutton found his definitive proof in 1788 at Siccar Point, a rocky promontory on the east coast of Scotland. There, he and his companions observed a dramatic junction: vertical layers of greywacke (a dark sandstone) were directly capped by horizontal layers of red sandstone. The sharp angle between the two rock formations demonstrated that the greywacke had been deposited, tilted vertically, eroded down to a flat surface, and then covered by the red sandstone over countless eons. The sheer scale of time required for these sequential processes to occur shattered the catastrophist timeline.

Which of the following best describes the relationship between Paragraph 3 and Paragraph 2?

  1. Paragraph 3 describes the specific field discovery that provided the physical evidence Hutton needed to support the theory introduced in Paragraph 2.Cevap
  2. B
    Paragraph 3 introduces a set of geological phenomena that directly challenge the theoretical framework of uniformitarianism outlined in Paragraph 2.
  3. C
    Paragraph 3 explains the historical origins of the eighteenth-century catastrophist timeline that Hutton sought to defend in Paragraph 2.
  4. D
    Paragraph 3 details the gradual, modern geological forces that are first defined as the core mechanisms of catastrophism in Paragraph 2.

Cevap

Paragraph 3 describes the specific field discovery that provided the physical evidence Hutton needed to support the theory introduced in Paragraph 2.
The correct answer is correct because Paragraph 2 establishes that James Hutton needed empirical evidence of "unconformities" to support his theory of uniformitarianism. Paragraph 3 then describes his discovery of a classic unconformity at Siccar Point, demonstrating that it served as the physical proof required by the theory.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze the content and function of Paragraph 2.
Paragraph 2 introduces Hutton's theory of uniformitarianism and notes that he needed to locate physical evidence of "unconformities" to support this theory.
This establishes the theoretical context and requirements that the subsequent paragraph must address.
2
Analyze the content and function of Paragraph 3.
Paragraph 3 describes the discovery of a specific geological junction at Siccar Point that meets the definition of an unconformity.
This identifies the concrete application or evidence presented in the text.
3
Evaluate the relationship between the two paragraphs.
Paragraph 3 provides the concrete, empirical evidence that Paragraph 2 states is necessary to prove the theory.
This directly matches the relationship described in the correct option.

Anahtar Kavram

Identifying how subsequent paragraphs provide evidence for theories or claims introduced earlier in a text.
Bu soruyu puanla