Soru

Zorluk: ZorEstablishing Introductions and Thesis Statements

Consider the following draft of a passage about marine biology:

[1] __________________________________________________ [2] In December 1938, Marjorie Courtenay-Latimer, a curious museum curator in East London, South Africa, received a call from a local trawler captain who had brought in an unusual catch. Amid the pile of sharks and rays, she noticed a strange, five-foot-long fish with thick, iridescent blue scales and lobe-like fins that resembled limbs. Sensing its importance, she brought the specimen to her museum and contacted ichthyologist J.L.B. Smith. Smith famously identified the fish as a coelacanth, a primitive species previously known only from fossils dating back to the Cretaceous period.

This 'living fossil' provided biologists with a rare opportunity to study a creature whose anatomy had remained virtually unchanged for millions of years. Its lobe-like fins, which contain bones arranged similarly to those in land vertebrates, offered a direct physical link between ancient fish and the first tetrapods that crawled onto land. The discovery not only filled a massive gap in the fossil record but also prompted scientists to reconsider how species adapt over vast spans of geological time.

Which choice, if added at [1], provides the most effective introduction to the passage by establishing its central thesis?

  1. A
    Curators of natural history museums frequently rely on commercial fishing fleets to find specimens, they must examine daily catches carefully.
  2. B
    Although the coelacanth was long assumed to have vanished from the Earth along with the dinosaurs during the Cretaceous period.
  3. The unexpected discovery of the coelacanth in the twentieth century upended the scientific consensus on extinction and provided a living window into evolutionary history.Cevap
  4. D
    While many prehistoric marine creatures are known only through fossilized remains, the classification of these ancient specimens are highly debated by ichthyologists.

Cevap

The correct choice is the option stating that the unexpected discovery of the coelacanth upended scientific consensus on extinction and provided a living window into evolutionary history.
The correct option effectively introduces the passage by bringing up the coelacanth and outlining the main thesis: that its discovery challenged beliefs about extinction and provided crucial evolutionary evidence. This sets up both the story of the 1938 discovery in the first paragraph and the evolutionary analysis in the second paragraph.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze the passage to determine its main focus and theme.
The first paragraph describes the discovery of the coelacanth in 1938, while the second paragraph discusses how the species serves as an evolutionary link between fish and land vertebrates.
An effective introduction must establish a thesis that encompasses both the narrative of the discovery and its evolutionary implications.
2
Evaluate the grammatical correctness of the options to eliminate structural errors.
Three options contain grammatical errors: one is a comma splice, another is a dependent clause fragment, and a third has a subject-verb agreement issue.
Regardless of rhetorical fit, options containing grammar or punctuation errors must be eliminated on the ACT English section.
3
Compare the remaining grammatically correct option to the rhetorical goal.
The option introducing the coelacanth's discovery and its impact on theories of extinction and evolution is grammatically sound and fits the passage's overall development.
This choice establishes a clear, complete thesis that unifies the detailed history and scientific analysis presented in the text.

Anahtar Kavram

Establishing Introductions and Thesis Statements
Bu soruyu puanla