Soru

Zorluk: OrtaEvaluating Supporting Evidence

Passage

Biologists observing Australian bushfires have long noted that raptors, such as the black kite (*Milvus migrans*) and brown falcon (*Falco berigora*), congregate at fire fronts to capture escaping prey. However, a study by Bonta et al. proposes a far more active role: these birds act as 'pyrophiles' that intentionally propagate fire by carrying burning twigs in their talons to unburned areas. Skeptics argue that this behavior is accidental, suggesting that birds merely drop embers while retrieving prey. To evaluate these competing interpretations, researchers analyzed three key behavioral patterns: first, multiple birds systematically carrying embers to the same unburned patch; second, the selection of smoldering hardwood twigs over lighter, fast-burning grass; and third, the directional movement of birds against prevailing winds to start new fire lines, maximizing prey exposure. These observations suggest a deliberate ecological strategy rather than sporadic, accidental occurrences. By starting new fires, the raptors force prey out of previously safe havens, suggesting that the behavior is a coordinated hunting tactic.

Question

Based on the passage, match each of the researchers' claims about raptor behavior on the left with the specific evidence that supports it on the right.

  • The fire-spreading behavior is a coordinated collective effort rather than an isolated action.Observations of multiple raptors systematically carrying embers to the same unburned area.
  • The birds demonstrate an understanding of which materials are effective for transporting fire.The preference shown by the birds for smoldering hardwood twigs over light grass.
  • The fire-spreading behavior is strategically oriented to maximize prey capture.The directional movement of the birds against prevailing winds to start new fire lines.

Cevap

The correct pairings match: (1) the collective effort claim with observations of multiple raptors carrying embers, (2) the understanding of materials claim with the selection of hardwood twigs, and (3) the hunting strategy claim with directional movement against winds.
The correct matches accurately align each of the author's theoretical claims with the corresponding empirical evidence from the passage. Specifically, the claim of coordinated collective effort is supported by the observation of multiple raptors carrying embers to the same unburned spot; the claim of understanding effective materials is supported by the selection of smoldering hardwood twigs over light grass; and the claim of hunting strategy is supported by the movement of birds against prevailing winds.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the core claims made in the passage regarding raptor pyrophilic behavior.
The claims are: coordinated collective effort, understanding of effective fire-spreading materials, and strategic hunting orientation.
To evaluate supporting evidence, one must first isolate the specific claims that require evidence.
2
Locate the specific empirical observations or evidence associated with each claim in the passage.
The passage lists: multiple birds carrying embers to the same patch (supports coordination); choosing hardwood twigs over grass (supports material selectivity); and flying against wind to start new fires (supports hunting strategy).
Aligning each claim with its corresponding textual evidence ensures a direct logical connection without relying on external assumptions.

Anahtar Kavram

Evaluating Supporting Evidence
Tahmini Süre:1m 30s
Bu soruyu puanla