Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: OrtaDistinguishing Fact from Opinion and Bias

Read the following English translation of an editorial from a Chilean newspaper regarding the transition to electric public transit in Santiago:

"In 2024, Santiago successfully integrated over 2,000 electric buses into its public transit system, making it the city with the largest electric bus fleet in the Americas. This transition has resulted in a 30% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions along major transit corridors. According to city transit authorities, the buses operate with significantly lower noise levels than traditional diesel buses. However, local business owners in the downtown area claim that the construction of new charging terminals has temporarily reduced customer foot traffic by 15%. While transit planners view the fleet as a monumental triumph of modern engineering and an essential step toward ecological harmony, some community organizers argue that the project's high cost has diverted essential funding from public healthcare. Ultimately, the city's investment represents the most visionary environmental initiative of the decade, showcasing Santiago's role as a leader in global sustainability."

Which of the following assertions from the editorial represents the author's own subjective opinion rather than a reported perspective or a verifiable fact?

  1. A
    Santiago integrated more than 2,000 electric buses into its public transit system in 2024.
  2. B
    The construction of new charging terminals caused a temporary 15% reduction in customer foot traffic.
  3. The city's investment in the electric bus fleet is the most visionary environmental initiative of the decade.Cevap
  4. D
    The electric buses operate with lower noise levels than traditional diesel buses.

Cevap

The statement describing the city's investment as the most visionary environmental initiative of the decade represents the author's subjective opinion.
The assertion that the city's investment represents the most visionary environmental initiative of the decade is a subjective opinion. It uses value-laden, superlative language ('most visionary') to express a personal judgment that cannot be objectively verified or measured, and it is presented directly as the author's concluding evaluation.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze the passage to identify the nature of each claim.
Identify verifiable statistics (2,000 buses, 30% emissions reduction, 15% foot traffic reduction) and reported perspectives (planners' views, organizers' views).
This establishes a baseline to separate objective data and third-party reports from the author's own editorial voice.
2
Examine the concluding sentence for subjective language.
Recognize that 'most visionary environmental initiative' contains a value judgment and subjective superlative phrasing.
Superlatives and value-based adjectives indicate a personal opinion or bias rather than a verifiable fact.
3
Determine which option aligns with the author's subjective opinion.
Match the subjective statement in the conclusion with the correct option.
This confirms the correct option as it directly expresses the author's personal evaluation of the project's significance.

Anahtar Kavram

Distinguishing Fact from Opinion and Bias
Tahmini Süre:1m 30s
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Distinguishing Fact from Opinion and Bias

Bu konudan daha fazla soru