Soru

Zorluk: ZorLabor Movements and Gilded Age Conflict

Read the following excerpt from testimony given before the Senate Committee on Education and Labor in 1883:

'The trade has been subdivided and those subdivisions have been again subdivided, so a man never learns the machinist's trade now... In the place of a boy learning a trade, he is put on a machine to run it, and he is kept on that machine... It has a very deforming effect upon the mind and brain, as well as the character of the man... he becomes a mere machine himself.'

The technological and industrial changes described in the excerpt most directly contributed to which of the following developments during the late nineteenth century?

  1. A
    A widespread return to localized, household-based production systems that bypassed urban factory networks
  2. B
    The federal government's strict maintenance of a laissez-faire stance by refusing to intervene in labor-management conflicts
  3. The rise of broad-based labor organizations like the Knights of Labor that welcomed unskilled and semi-skilled workersCevap
  4. D
    The political dominance of the Progressive Party in passing federal laws that prohibited the mechanization of craft industries

Cevap

The rise of broad-based labor organizations like the Knights of Labor that welcomed unskilled and semi-skilled workers
The correct answer is correct because industrialization and the subdivision of labor led to 'deskilling,' which stripped workers of specialized craft autonomy. Because workers who ran single machines were easily replaced, labor leaders recognized the need for broad-based industrial unions—such as the Knights of Labor—that could organize both skilled and unskilled workers to exert collective power.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze the stimulus passage.
The excerpt details how the division of labor and mechanization have subdivided the machinist's trade, replacing comprehensive craft apprenticeship with repetitive machine operation, leading to a process known as deskilling.
Understanding the core historical process described in the source is necessary to link it to the correct historical consequence.
2
Connect deskilling to late nineteenth-century labor dynamics.
Deskilled workers were easily replaceable and lost individual bargaining leverage. Consequently, traditional craft unions (which only represented highly skilled artisans) were poorly suited for the new industrial workforce, driving the creation of inclusive industrial unions.
This step connects the industrial change to the organizational strategy of Gilded Age labor movements.
3
Evaluate the choices and identify the correct option.
The option describing the rise of broad-based labor organizations like the Knights of Labor correctly identifies the organizational response to the deskilling of industrial work.
Selecting the response that accurately aligns with Gilded Age labor trends while rejecting options based on common historical misconceptions.

Anahtar Kavram

The deskilling of the Gilded Age industrial workforce and the rise of inclusive labor organizing strategies.
Bu soruyu puanla