Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: Çok zorWeakening Arguments

Hospitals in competitive metropolitan areas frequently suffer substantial revenue loss when surgical procedures are delayed due to sterilizer equipment failure. To eliminate these losses, a regional hospital network plans to replace all of its steam-autoclave sterilizers with modern hydrogen peroxide gas plasma units. Because gas plasma units complete a sterilization cycle in one-third the time required by steam autoclaves, hospital administrators conclude that adopting gas plasma units will virtually eliminate surgical delays caused by equipment unavailability.

Which of the following, if true, most seriously undermines the hospital administrators' conclusion?

  1. Gas plasma units require specialized synthetic containment trays that degrade rapidly under routine use, necessitating mandatory cooling and safety inspection periods that offline the units for longer total duration each week than steam autoclaves.Cevap
  2. B
    Surgeons across the hospital network report high satisfaction with gas plasma units because the lower operating temperature preserves the sharpness of delicate micro-surgical instruments.
  3. C
    The initial capital cost of acquiring gas plasma units exceeds the annual budget allocated for emergency instrument maintenance across all network hospitals.
  4. D
    Patient satisfaction ratings in metropolitan hospitals are primarily determined by post-operative care quality rather than whether surgical start times adhere to scheduled schedules.
  5. E
    Steam-autoclave sterilizers consume significantly more electrical energy per operating cycle than hydrogen peroxide gas plasma units.

Cevap

The argument is most weakened by the finding that gas plasma units require frequent inspection and cooling downtime for synthetic trays, resulting in greater overall weekly equipment unavailability than steam autoclaves.
The correct answer identifies an operational constraint—frequent inspection and cooling periods for specialized containment trays—that causes gas plasma units to be offline for longer cumulative periods overall than the older steam autoclaves. Even though each sterilization cycle is individually faster, the increased maintenance downtime reduces total equipment availability, directly contradicting the administrators' conclusion that surgical delays due to unavailable equipment will be eliminated.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Deconstruct the core argument
Premise: Gas plasma sterilizers complete individual cycles in one-third the time of steam autoclaves. Conclusion: Replacing steam autoclaves with gas plasma units will eliminate surgical delays caused by equipment unavailability.
Identifying the link between the premise (faster cycle time) and conclusion (reduced overall equipment downtime) exposes the unstated assumption that faster cycle times equal greater total equipment availability.
2
Identify the unstated logical gap
The argument assumes no secondary factors (such as maintenance, inspection, or failure rates) will offset the time saved during individual sterilization cycles.
To weaken a plan-to-goal argument, an option must demonstrate an unintended side effect or constraint that prevents the goal from being achieved.
3
Evaluate the choices against the central gap
The option revealing that maintenance safety inspections offline the gas plasma units for longer total durations per week directly breaks the assumption and proves equipment unavailability will persist or worsen.
This fact directly undermines the conclusion that surgical delays caused by equipment unavailability will be eliminated.

Anahtar Kavram

Weakening Causal and Plan-to-Goal Arguments via Unintended Operational Bottlenecks
Tahmini Süre:2m 0s
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Weakening Arguments

Bu konudan daha fazla soru