Strengthening Arguments

21 soru

Tüm türler21 Çoktan seçmeli12 Çoklu seçim9

Researchers analyzing high-altitude bristlecone pine growth rings in the White Mountains observed a sudden, sharp contraction in tree-ring width dating precisely to 536 CE. Historical records from the Mediterranean basin during the same decade describe several years of dimmed sunlight and summer frosts. The researchers concluded that a major volcanic eruption in 536 CE ejected massive sulfate aerosols into the stratosphere, blocking solar radiation and causing global cooling that restricted tree growth. Which of the following, if true, provides the strongest support for the researchers' conclusion?

Modern volcanic eruptions emitting similar volumes of sulfur dioxide produce atmospheric cooling effects that typically abate within two to three years.

Polar ice core samples retrieved from layers dated to 536 CE contain unprecedentedly high concentrations of atmospheric volcanic sulfate deposits.

Bristlecone pines at lower elevations in the same mountain range exhibited normal growth ring expansion throughout the decade starting in 536 CE.

A severe regional drought affected the southwestern North American continent during the middle of the sixth century.

Mediterranean historical records from the late sixth century report a gradual recovery of crop yields across the region.

Cevabı ve açıklamayı göster

Cevap: Polar ice core samples retrieved from layers dated to 536 CE contain unprecedentedly high concentrations of atmospheric volcanic sulfate deposits.

Cevap

The correct answer is the option stating that polar ice core samples from 536 CE contain unprecedentedly high concentrations of atmospheric volcanic sulfate deposits.

The correct answer provides direct physical proof of massive atmospheric volcanic aerosols precisely in 536 CE from independent ice core data. This strongly reinforces the conclusion that a volcanic eruption was the cause of both the Mediterranean atmospheric phenomenon and the tree-ring growth contraction.

Adım Adım Çözüm

Deconstruct the argument into premise and conclusion.

Premise 1: Sharp narrowing of tree rings in 536 CE. Premise 2: Mediterranean historical records report dimmed sunlight/frosts in 536 CE. Conclusion: A major volcanic eruption in 536 CE caused global stratospheric cooling that restricted tree growth.

Identifying the gap between observed evidence (tree rings, dimmed sun) and the proposed cause (volcanic eruption) is essential for evaluating strengthening statements.

Identify what evidence would strengthen the causal claim.

Direct physical evidence confirming an eruption occurred in 536 CE, or ruling out alternative causes for the tree-ring contraction.

Strengthening questions require corroborating the specific mechanism or cause proposed by the author.

Evaluate the choices against the required strengthening effect.

Finding volcanic sulfate deposits in polar ice cores dated to 536 CE provides independent, direct physical verification of a global volcanic eruption in that exact year.

This confirms the unstated physical bridge between the tree-ring anomaly and the hypothesized volcanic cause.

Anahtar Kavram

Strengthening Causal Claims via Independent Physical Corroboration

Tahmini Süre:1m 30s

ÖncekiSayfa 2 / 2

Strengthening Arguments

Cevap

Adım Adım Çözüm

Anahtar Kavram

Sık Yapılan Hatalar