Soru

Zorluk: Çok zorIdentification of Main Idea and Supporting Details

Read the passage below carefully and answer the question that follows.

For centuries, scholarship on pre-colonial West African urbanism focused primarily on administrative centers as transient settlement clusters rather than enduring architectural achievements. Recent geo-archaeological surveys of the ancient earthworks of Benin, however, have fundamentally revised this perspective. Spanning thousands of kilometers in a complex network of banks and ditches, these ramparts represented not merely defensive perimeters constructed in response to external military threats, as early colonial chroniclers posited, but a sophisticated, long-term system of land management and territorial boundary delineation. The labor allocation required for their continuous maintenance reflects a centralized yet highly coordinated agrarian economy capable of mobilizing massive communal resources across generations. By integrating soil micro-stratigraphy with oral traditions, contemporary historians now demonstrate that the earthworks primarily served to regulate agricultural zoning and resource distribution among interconnected rural communities. Consequently, viewing the Benin walls through a purely militaristic lens obscures their primary function as an unprecedented monument to civil engineering, socio-spatial organization, and sustainable territorial governance.

Which of the following best expresses the central thesis of the passage?

  1. The ancient Benin earthworks functioned primarily as an advanced system of territorial governance and socio-spatial organization rather than mere military defenses.Cevap
  2. B
    The continuous upkeep of the Benin ramparts required a centralized agrarian economy that mobilized communal resources across generations.
  3. C
    Early colonial chroniclers accurately documented that the Benin earthworks were built exclusively to counter external military invasion.
  4. D
    Soil micro-stratigraphy and oral traditions prove that pre-colonial West African societies lacked organized urban planning prior to the Benin earthworks.

Cevap

The central thesis of the passage is that the ancient Benin earthworks served primarily as an advanced system of territorial governance and socio-spatial organization rather than simple military defenses.
The correct answer accurately summarizes the central thesis developed throughout the passage. The author moves from contrasting old colonial interpretations to demonstrating through recent research that the earthworks were fundamentally a system of civil engineering, land management, and socio-spatial organization.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the overall structure and controlling idea of the passage.
The text contrasts an older view (that Benin walls were just military defenses or transient settlements) with modern geo-archaeological findings.
Understanding the contrast helps isolate the author's primary argument from secondary claims.
2
Distinguish between the overarching main idea and specific supporting evidence.
Details about soil micro-stratigraphy, labor allocation, and colonial chroniclers serve as evidence supporting the conclusion stated in the final sentence.
The thesis statement in a dense academic passage is often explicitly synthesized in the concluding sentence.
3
Match the synthesized argument to the correct option.
The option emphasizing territorial governance and socio-spatial organization over mere military defense directly mirrors the author's concluding thesis.
The correct option must cover the full scope of the text without narrowing into a single supporting factual detail.

Anahtar Kavram

Identifying Main Idea vs Supporting Details in Complex Passages
Bu soruyu puanla