Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: ZorAd Hominem (Source Argument)

Mayor Lin proposes a comprehensive plan to reduce municipal waste, arguing that the city's landfill will reach capacity within five years based on current disposal rates. In response, a city council member argues that the proposal should be rejected because Mayor Lin's own private business was recently fined for illegal dumping, demonstrating her lack of genuine commitment to environmental sustainability.

The council member's rebuttal successfully undermines Mayor Lin's argument by exposing a fundamental contradiction in the substantive premises of the waste reduction plan.

Cevap: Cevap

Cevap

The statement is False.
The statement inaccurately describes the logical function of the council member's rebuttal. By attacking Mayor Lin's past business practices, the council member attacks the source's character and motives (an ad hominem flaw) rather than engaging with the substantive factual premises regarding the landfill's capacity and current disposal rates.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze Mayor Lin's original argument.
Premise: The landfill will reach capacity in five years based on current rates. Conclusion: A comprehensive waste reduction plan is needed.
To establish the substantive claims and the logical structure of the primary argument.
2
Analyze the council member's rebuttal.
Premise: Mayor Lin's private business was fined for illegal dumping. Conclusion: The proposal should be rejected.
To identify the method of reasoning used to counter the original argument.
3
Evaluate the target of the council member's critique.
The rebuttal focuses entirely on Mayor Lin's character, behavior, and hypocrisy, ignoring the data about the landfill.
To determine whether the rebuttal addresses substantive premises or merely proponent characteristics.
4
Assess the given statement against the logical structure.
The statement incorrectly claims the rebuttal exposes a contradiction in the 'substantive premises', when it actually attacks the source.
To yield the final true/false evaluation.

Anahtar Kavram

Ad Hominem (Source Argument - Tu Quoque)
Tahmini Süre:1m 30s
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Ad Hominem (Source Argument)

Bu konudan daha fazla soru