Soru

Zorluk: OrtaInterpreting Figurative Language

For centuries, the prevailing cosmological model envisioned a universe that functioned as a great biological organism. Celestial bodies were thought to move out of an innate desire to reach their natural resting places, imbued with a teleological purpose akin to living creatures seeking nourishment. However, the scientific revolution of the seventeenth century, spearheaded by figures such as Galileo and Newton, effectively dismantled this organicist paradigm. In its place, they constructed a 'clockwork universe,' a vast, intricate apparatus governed by inflexible, mathematically precise laws of motion.

In this new conceptual framework, the cosmos was stripped of its animating spirit and reduced to mere matter in motion. The planets did not 'desire' to orbit the sun; they were compelled to do so by gravitational forces operating blindly across the void. The profound implication of this shift was not merely mathematical, but philosophical. By excising the 'vital breath' from the universe, the mechanists created a rift between the observer and the observed. Nature was no longer a sympathetic entity with which humanity shared a cosmic kinship, but an indifferent machine whose gears could be understood only through cold, detached calculation.

Based on the passage, the phrase "excising the 'vital breath'" refers to the act of

  1. eliminating the assumption that the natural world is guided by an inherent, animating purposeCevap
  2. B
    physically extracting the atmospheric elements necessary for biological respiration from the celestial realm
  3. C
    compelling the planets to orbit the sun through the blind operation of gravitational forces
  4. D
    overturning the theological dogmas that had previously constrained scientific inquiry
  5. E
    irrevocably severing all potential philosophical ties between human observers and the cosmos

Cevap

The phrase refers to eliminating the assumption that the natural world is guided by an inherent, animating purpose.
The correct answer accurately synthesizes the passage's discussion of a philosophical shift in cosmology. The author uses 'vital breath' as a metaphor for the 'animating spirit' or 'teleological purpose' that characterized the pre-Newtonian, organicist view of the universe. 'Excising' this breath refers to the mechanists' removal of this inherent, living purpose from their scientific models, thereby reducing the cosmos to 'mere matter in motion'.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze the metaphorical phrase within its immediate sentence.
The phrase is used to describe how the mechanists 'created a rift' between humanity and nature, changing nature into an 'indifferent machine'.
Understanding the immediate context provides the functional role of the phrase in the author's argument.
2
Trace the phrase back to earlier concepts in the passage to define 'vital breath'.
Earlier in the text, the author describes the old paradigm as treating the universe as a 'biological organism' with an 'animating spirit' and a 'teleological purpose'.
Metaphorical language in LSAT passages almost always refers back to explicitly stated concepts from earlier in the text.
3
Synthesize the meaning of the action being described.
To 'excise' this breath means to remove this living, animating spirit—specifically the assumption of intrinsic purpose—from the scientific understanding of the cosmos.
Combining the definition of the metaphor with the action taken by the mechanists yields the correct interpretation.

Anahtar Kavram

Interpreting Figurative Language
Bu soruyu puanla