Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: OrtaCross-Text Connections: Relational Synthesis

Text 1
Archaeologist Iégor Reznikoff argues that the placement of Upper Paleolithic cave art was deliberately determined by the acoustic properties of the cave chambers. Reznikoff posits that prehistoric artists navigated pitch-black cave networks by using vocal hums to locate areas with high acoustic resonance. Once a resonant chamber was identified, they marked it with paintings, suggesting that sound played a central role in ritualistic art creation.

Text 2
Researcher Amanda Ruiz and colleagues investigated Reznikoff’s hypothesis by measuring the acoustic properties of several French caves containing Upper Paleolithic artwork. While Ruiz’s team confirmed that many chambers featuring cave paintings indeed exhibited high acoustic resonance, they also discovered numerous highly resonant chambers that lacked any art. Ruiz concludes that resonance alone cannot account for the placement of cave paintings, as other factors must have influenced prehistoric site selection.

Based on the passages, how would Ruiz and colleagues (Text 2) most likely characterize Reznikoff’s hypothesis (Text 1)?

  1. A
    As entirely refuted by their findings that chambers with cave paintings do not exhibit high acoustic resonance.
  2. As partially consistent with their measurements of decorated chambers but insufficient on its own to explain prehistoric site selection.Cevap
  3. C
    As a hypothesis that is highly plausible but cannot be tested without reproducing the specific vocal hums of prehistoric artists.
  4. D
    As a compelling explanation that is supported by the fact that prehistoric artists used paint pigments to enhance the resonance of cave walls.

Cevap

As partially consistent with their measurements of decorated chambers but insufficient on its own to explain prehistoric site selection.
The correct option is supported because the researchers in Text 2 found that while many decorated chambers did have high resonance (supporting Reznikoff's claim in Text 1), there were also many highly resonant chambers that did not contain any artwork. Therefore, they would view the hypothesis as partially supported but incomplete on its own.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the core claim in Text 1.
Reznikoff claims that acoustic resonance drove prehistoric artists to select specific cave locations for artwork.
Establishing the target hypothesis to be evaluated.
2
Identify the findings and conclusion in Text 2.
Ruiz's team verified high resonance in decorated chambers, but also found high resonance in chambers without artwork, concluding that resonance cannot be the sole factor.
Analyzing the empirical evidence that tests the hypothesis.
3
Synthesize the relationship between the two texts.
The hypothesis is partially aligned with the measurements of decorated chambers, but incomplete because it cannot account for the empty resonant chambers.
Determining how the author of the second text characterizes the argument of the first.

Anahtar Kavram

Cross-Text Connections: Relational Synthesis
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Cross-Text Connections: Relational Synthesis

Bu konudan daha fazla soru