Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: OrtaStatement and Assumptions

The state agriculture department recently issued the following directive:

"To halt the rapid depletion of groundwater reserves in the western districts, the cultivation of sugarcane is prohibited in these areas with immediate effect. A parallel financial incentive scheme will be launched for farmers transitioning to millet farming."

Based on the statement above, which of the following assumptions are implicit in the department's directive? (Select all valid assumptions)

  1. Millet farming consumes substantially less groundwater compared to sugarcane cultivation.Cevap
  2. Providing financial incentives is an effective strategy to encourage farmers to adopt different agricultural practices.Cevap
  3. C
    The state's overall production of sugarcane will experience a severe decline in the upcoming harvest season.
  4. D
    Sugarcane cultivation is the sole cause of water scarcity across all geographical regions of the state.

Cevap

The correct assumptions are that millet consumes less water than sugarcane, and that financial incentives will effectively encourage farmers to change their crops.
The correct assumptions identify the necessary conditions for the policy to work. For the substitution to halt water depletion, the new crop (millet) must logically use less water than the banned crop (sugarcane). Furthermore, offering financial support inherently assumes that such incentives are a viable way to drive behavioral change among the farmers.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze the primary goal and actions presented in the statement.
The goal is to halt groundwater depletion in western districts. The actions are banning sugarcane and offering financial incentives to grow millet.
Identifying the core components of the directive helps isolate what must be true for the directive to make logical sense.
2
Evaluate the premise behind the crop substitution strategy.
The department must assume that growing millet will use significantly less water than growing sugarcane.
If millet consumed the same or more water than sugarcane, the substitution would fail to achieve the primary goal of saving groundwater.
3
Evaluate the premise behind the financial strategy.
The department must assume that offering money will persuade farmers to comply and switch crops.
Policies utilizing financial incentives inherently assume that those incentives are an effective catalyst for behavioral change.
4
Differentiate between implicit assumptions and logical inferences.
A drop in future sugarcane production is a consequence (inference), not an underlying premise (assumption). Broad generalizations about the entire state's water scarcity are external exaggerations.
Assumptions must be foundational pillars required before the statement is made, not outcomes that happen after the statement is executed.

Anahtar Kavram

Statement and Assumptions
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Statement and Assumptions

Bu konudan daha fazla soru