Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: Çok zorPassage Assumptions and Underlying Premises

Read the following passage carefully:

To mitigate systemic agrarian distress in drought-prone semi-arid regions, state policy advisors have proposed replacing flat electricity subsidies for agricultural pump-sets with a direct conditional cash transfer linked to soil moisture sensors. Under this scheme, farmers receive a fixed quarterly income support stipend, but only if their groundwater extraction does not exceed a localized seasonal quota determined by real-time aquifer monitoring. Proponents argue that replacing price-distorting energy subsidies with baseline income transfers will incentivize farmers to shift from water-intensive cash crops to drought-resilient millets, thereby preventing rapid aquifer depletion while preserving farm incomes. However, critics point out that electricity subsidies currently cushion smallholders against volatile diesel costs during dry spells.

Which one of the following expresses the most crucial underlying assumption on which the policy advisors' proposal is based?

  1. Farmers' cropping decisions in semi-arid regions are substantially influenced by the financial structure of energy subsidies rather than unalterable market or ecological constraints.Cevap
  2. B
    Direct conditional cash transfers provide greater overall financial stability to smallholder farmers than flat electricity subsidies during severe drought years.
  3. C
    Drought-resilient millets command higher market prices and consumer demand in urban centers than traditional water-intensive cash crops.
  4. D
    Installing real-time soil moisture sensors will completely eliminate unauthorized groundwater extraction across all agricultural holdings.

Cevap

The policy advisors' proposal relies on the underlying assumption that farmers' cropping choices are responsive to energy subsidy structures rather than being completely dictated by unalterable market or ecological factors.
The correct option identifies the fundamental bridge between the policy mechanism (altering energy subsidies) and the expected behavioral outcome (switching crop types). For the proposal to function as intended, farmers must have the flexibility to change crops in response to energy cost structures. If their choices were rigidly constrained by external factors, changing subsidies would fail to alter cropping patterns, invalidating the argument.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the author's core conclusion and proposed mechanism.
The proposal asserts that replacing flat electricity subsidies with conditional cash transfers tied to groundwater extraction quotas will incentivize farmers to switch from water-intensive cash crops to drought-resilient millets.
An assumption is an unstated, necessary premise that connects the proposed intervention (subsidies/quotas) to the desired objective (crop transition and aquifer conservation).
2
Apply the Negation Test to the candidate assumption.
Negating the statement gives: 'Farmers' cropping decisions are NOT influenced by energy subsidy structures and ARE dictated by unalterable market or ecological constraints.'
If crop choices are entirely unalterable regardless of energy subsidies, changing the subsidy mechanism will have zero effect on crop selection, causing the entire proposal to collapse.
3
Evaluate and eliminate distractors based on error taxonomy.
Distractor options confuse assumptions with inferences, external factual claims about urban millet prices, or extreme conditions of total enforcement perfection.
A valid assumption must be strictly necessary for the argument's logic to hold.

Anahtar Kavram

Passage Assumptions and Necessary Premises
Tahmini Süre:2m 0s
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Passage Assumptions and Underlying Premises

Bu konudan daha fazla soru