Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: OrtaCourse of Action

Statement: Due to a massive influx of tourists during the annual heritage festival, the main suspension bridge connecting the historical district to the city center has begun showing signs of critical structural stress. Engineers have warned of a potential collapse if the current heavy pedestrian traffic is allowed to continue unchecked.

Courses of Action:
I. The city administration should immediately halt all pedestrian movement on the bridge and deploy structural engineering teams for an emergency integrity assessment.
II. The local authorities should completely cancel the heritage festival and mandate all tourists to leave the city immediately to drastically reduce crowd density.

Which of the following logically follows as a valid course of action?

  1. Only course of action I followsCevap
  2. B
    Only course of action II follows
  3. C
    Both courses of action I and II follow
  4. D
    Neither course of action I nor II follows

Cevap

Only course of action I follows
A valid course of action must be a practical, immediate, and proportionate response to the specific problem. Halting traffic and assessing the bridge directly mitigates the risk of collapse without causing unnecessary widespread panic. Course I achieves this perfectly.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze the core problem presented in the statement.
The primary issue is an immediate threat of structural failure on a highly trafficked suspension bridge due to excessive pedestrian load.
Identifying the exact scope of the problem is necessary to evaluate the appropriateness of proposed solutions.
2
Evaluate Course of Action I against the criteria of feasibility and proportionality.
Halting bridge traffic and deploying engineers is a direct, practical, and standard safety protocol that solves the immediate problem without causing undue harm.
Administrative actions must directly address the crisis while following logical safety procedures.
3
Evaluate Course of Action II against the same criteria.
Canceling the entire festival and forcibly removing tourists is a massive overreaction. The problem is localized to the bridge, not the entire city.
Administrative decisions must avoid extreme, blanket punitive measures when a localized, manageable solution exists.

Anahtar Kavram

Course of Action Evaluation and Administrative Proportionality
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Course of Action

Bu konudan daha fazla soru