Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: OrtaStatement and Assumptions

The city council recently published a new environmental directive. Based on the text below, which underlying assumptions must the council be relying upon? (Select all that apply)

Directive:
To combat the alarming decline in the local sparrow population, the council has initiated a program distributing free wooden birdhouses and urging citizens to install them in their balconies and gardens.

  1. Citizens will be cooperative and willing to install the distributed birdhouses in their personal spaces.Cevap
  2. The unavailability of suitable nesting spaces is a major factor contributing to the decline of the sparrow population.Cevap
  3. C
    The number of sparrows in the city will demonstrably increase in the next breeding season due to this initiative.
  4. D
    Sparrows have completely lost their biological ability to construct natural nests without human intervention.

Cevap

The implicit assumptions are that citizens will be willing to participate in the initiative by installing the birdhouses, and that the lack of suitable nesting spaces is a significant contributing factor to the sparrow population decline.
An assumption is an unstated premise that must be true for a proposed action to be logically valid. For the city council's birdhouse distribution program to be a rational decision, two things must be true beforehand: first, that the lack of nesting locations is actually a cause of the sparrow decline (otherwise the physical intervention is pointless), and second, that citizens will actively participate by installing them (otherwise the community intervention fails). Both of these are valid implicit assumptions required by the text.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze the given statement to identify the core administrative action and its intended goal.
The action is distributing free birdhouses to citizens. The goal is to combat the decline in the local sparrow population.
Understanding the proposed action and its ultimate goal is necessary to determine what unstated premises (assumptions) must exist for the decision to be logical.
2
Evaluate the option regarding citizen cooperation as a potential premise.
If citizens refuse to install the birdhouses, the program cannot achieve its goal. Therefore, the council must assume public willingness to participate.
Administrative directives that rely on voluntary public action inherently assume that the public will comply.
3
Evaluate the option regarding the lack of nesting spaces as a potential premise.
Providing birdhouses is a highly targeted solution. This implies the council believes the lack of such spaces is a primary cause of the population decline.
A targeted solution is only logical if it addresses a recognized root cause of the specific problem.
4
Differentiate between assumptions and expected outcomes or extreme factual claims for the remaining options.
The expectation of a population increase is a future consequence (inference), not an assumption. The claim about sparrows biologically losing their ability to build nests is an extreme factual distortion.
Assumptions are underlying conditions required for the action to make sense initially, not the future outcomes of the action or absolute factual exaggerations.

Anahtar Kavram

Identifying Implicit Premises in Administrative Courses of Action
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Statement and Assumptions

Bu konudan daha fazla soru