Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: Çok zorInference and Logical Deduction

Passage:
While market-based carbon pricing mechanisms like emissions trading schemes (ETS) are theoretically designed to internalize environmental externalities, their actual efficacy in developing economies hinges on institutional enforcement capacity and baseline market structures. In regions where informal economic sectors predominate and regulatory oversight is fragmented, high carbon compliance costs frequently induce industrial flight toward unregulated informal production rather than spurring capital investment in green technologies. Moreover, subsidized fossil fuel tariffs in these jurisdictions create contradictory economic signals, neutralizing the price disincentives imposed by carbon levies. Critics contend that implementing a stringent ETS framework without prior structural reforms to phase out fossil subsidies and formalize industrial monitoring simply redistributes carbon production to unmonitored sectors, leaving net national emissions unabated while shrinking the formal tax base. Consequently, climate policy experts emphasize that structural institutional alignment—specifically the removal of conflicting distortionary subsidies and the expansion of regulatory auditing capacity—is an indispensable prerequisite for market-based pricing tools to yield measurable decarbonization outcomes.

Based strictly on the arguments presented in the passage, which of the following statements must logically follow regarding market-based carbon pricing in developing economies?

  1. Carbon pricing mechanisms cannot guarantee national emission reductions if contradictory fossil fuel subsidies and unmonitored economic sectors remain unaddressed.Cevap
  2. B
    Developing nations should abandon market-based carbon pricing entirely and adopt command-and-control environmental regulations.
  3. C
    Imposing high carbon compliance costs directly leads to a net decrease in national carbon output by reducing formal industrial production.
  4. D
    Phasing out subsidized fossil fuel tariffs is alone sufficient to ensure that emissions trading schemes successfully stimulate green technological investments.

Cevap

Carbon pricing mechanisms cannot guarantee national emission reductions if contradictory fossil fuel subsidies and unmonitored economic sectors remain unaddressed.
The passage asserts that structural alignment (removing subsidies and enhancing regulatory oversight) is an indispensable prerequisite for carbon pricing to yield decarbonization outcomes. Logically, if the prerequisite is absent, the outcome cannot be guaranteed or achieved.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze the passage premises
The text states that in developing economies with large informal sectors and fossil fuel subsidies, carbon pricing shifts production to unmonitored areas and neutralized price signals, leaving net emissions unabated.
Establishing explicit facts given by the author.
2
Identify the author's logical conclusion
Removing distortionary subsidies and building auditing capacity are stated as 'indispensable prerequisites' for decarbonization through market pricing.
Connecting premises to the necessary condition established in the text.
3
Evaluate the valid logical inference
Without meeting the necessary prerequisites (addressing subsidies and unmonitored sectors), carbon pricing mechanisms cannot achieve the desired national emission reductions.
Applying formal logical contraposition (If P is necessary for Q, then Not P implies Not Q).

Anahtar Kavram

Deductive Necessity and Identifying Necessary Conditions in Reading Comprehension
Tahmini Süre:2m 30s
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Inference and Logical Deduction

Bu konudan daha fazla soru