Soru

Zorluk: OrtaPassage Assumptions and Underlying Premises

Read the following passage carefully:

"To mitigate severe groundwater depletion in semi-arid agricultural districts, the state water commission introduced a capital grant program for village councils to construct micro-watershed structures such as check dams and percolation tanks. The policy operates on a one-time reimbursement model, releasing funds only after structural completion is certified. Policy proponents assert that empowering local bodies with direct construction grants will rapidly rebuild regional aquifers and secure multi-cropping capacity for smallholders. However, hydrological audits reveal that without systematic annual desiltation, such earthen retention structures lose over sixty percent of their storage volume within three seasons. Because the grant framework explicitly excludes recurring operation and maintenance allocations, the long-term sustainability of the revived aquifers depends entirely on whether local communities independently organize and fund post-construction maintenance."

Based on the passage above, is the following statement TRUE or FALSE?

Statement: The author's conclusion that long-term aquifer sustainability depends on independent local community efforts assumes that state administrative bodies will not disburse supplementary maintenance grants once the initial construction funds are exhausted.

Cevap: Cevap

Cevap

True. The statement correctly identifies a necessary underlying assumption of the author's argument.
The statement is correct because the author's claim that long-term sustainability rests solely on independent community funding requires that no external government funding will be provided for ongoing maintenance. If such external funding were guaranteed or expected, the conclusion that local action is the sole determinant of success would fail.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the author's central conclusion in the passage.
The author concludes that long-term aquifer sustainability depends entirely on local communities independently organizing and funding post-construction maintenance.
The passage notes that earthen retention structures lose storage volume quickly without desiltation, and the policy explicitly excludes recurring maintenance funds.
2
Apply the negation test to the given statement to verify if it is an underlying assumption.
Negate the statement: 'State administrative bodies WILL disburse supplementary maintenance grants after initial funds are exhausted.'
If state bodies disburse supplementary maintenance grants, then sustainability does not depend entirely on independent community efforts, thereby undermining the author's conclusion.
3
Determine the validity of the statement based on the logical vulnerability revealed by the negation test.
Since negating the statement invalidates the author's main assertion, the statement represents an essential unstated assumption, making it True.
An assumption is an unstated premise required for an argument's conclusion to remain logically sound.

Anahtar Kavram

Identifying implicit assumptions and applying the negation test in reading comprehension arguments.
Bu soruyu puanla