Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: OrtaStatement and Assumptions

An urgent health bulletin released by the district administration states: "To combat the severe outbreak of waterborne infections, all citizens are advised to drink only boiled water for the next three months."

Evaluate the following candidate assumptions based on the given statement:
Assumption I: Boiling water is the only method available to completely eradicate waterborne pathogens.
Assumption II: A substantial number of citizens will read the bulletin and act upon the administration's advice.

Which of the following options correctly identifies the implicit assumption(s)?

  1. A
    Only assumption I is implicit
  2. Only assumption II is implicitCevap
  3. C
    Both assumptions I and II are implicit
  4. D
    Neither assumption I nor II is implicit

Cevap

Only assumption II is implicit
The correct answer accurately identifies that only the second assumption is implicit. In standard logical reasoning, whenever a notice, advisory, or appeal is issued, it is fundamentally assumed that it will be read and acted upon by a significant portion of its target audience. The first assumption is invalid because it introduces extreme exclusivity ('only method available') that is not a required premise for issuing the health bulletin.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze the main statement and its core intent.
The statement is a public advisory aimed at preventing waterborne infections by urging citizens to drink boiled water.
Understanding the nature of the statement (an administrative directive/advisory) is necessary to determine what conditions must be true for the statement to be made.
2
Evaluate Assumption I.
Assumption I claims boiling is the 'only method available'. The statement advises drinking 'only boiled water', but this does not logically necessitate that it is the sole existing scientific method to eradicate pathogens.
Implicit assumptions must not exaggerate or add extreme constraints beyond what is strictly necessary for the original statement to hold true.
3
Evaluate Assumption II.
Assumption II states that citizens will act upon the advice. This is a universally accepted premise in logical reasoning regarding public notices.
An authority would not issue a public advisory if they assumed the public would entirely ignore it. Therefore, expecting compliance is a necessary underlying premise.

Anahtar Kavram

Evaluating implicit premises in administrative advisories and recognizing extreme qualifiers.
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Statement and Assumptions

Bu konudan daha fazla soru