Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: OrtaStatement and Assumptions

Read the following municipal directive carefully and evaluate the candidate assumptions. Which of the following assumptions are logically implicit in the directive? (Select all that apply)

Directive: "To address changing transportation trends, the City Council mandates that all newly constructed commercial complexes with a parking capacity exceeding 50 vehicles must allocate at least 10% of their parking spaces for dedicated electric vehicle (EV) charging stations."

  1. A significant number of individuals visiting these new commercial complexes will be driving electric vehicles.Cevap
  2. Builders of new commercial complexes possess or can acquire the necessary technical and financial resources to install electric vehicle charging infrastructure.Cevap
  3. C
    Implementing this mandate will lead to a measurable improvement in the city's overall air quality over the next five years.
  4. D
    The global supply of fossil fuels is rapidly decreasing, necessitating an immediate shift to electric transportation.

Cevap

The implicit assumptions are that a significant number of visitors will use electric vehicles, and that builders have the capacity to install the required infrastructure.
The correct options represent unstated premises that must be true for the City Council's directive to be logical and executable. There must be an expected user base for the charging stations (the drivers), and the developers must have the practical ability to install them. Without these foundational premises, the mandate would be arbitrary and impossible to enforce.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze the stated directive and its primary motivation.
The directive requires large new commercial complexes to install EV chargers, motivated by 'changing transportation trends'.
Identifying explicit facts is the first step in determining what unstated premises must logically support them.
2
Test the assumption regarding visitor EV usage.
It is a valid assumption. The mandate would be irrational if the Council did not expect visitors to actually drive electric vehicles to these complexes.
An assumption must act as a necessary logical bridge; without expected users, the infrastructure mandate fails to make sense.
3
Test the assumption regarding developer capability.
It is a valid assumption. The Council must presume that builders can feasibly execute the installation.
Regulatory requirements implicitly assume that the subjects of the regulation have the means to comply.
4
Evaluate the remaining options for logical errors.
The statement about improving air quality is discarded as an inference. The statement about fossil fuel depletion is discarded as external knowledge.
Assumptions must be strictly required for the author's statement, differentiating them from likely consequences or outside facts.

Anahtar Kavram

Identifying Implicit Premises vs. Inferences and External Knowledge
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Statement and Assumptions

Bu konudan daha fazla soru