Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: OrtaCourse of Action

Statement: A pre-monsoon geological vulnerability report has warned of an exceptionally high risk of massive landslides along the sole arterial highway connecting the state's industrial hub to the eastern hilly districts.

Courses of Action:
I. The state disaster management authority should preemptively position earth-moving machinery, establish temporary medical camps, and set up a continuous monitoring grid along the identified vulnerable stretches.
II. The administration should permanently halt all vehicular movement on this highway and mandate that all civilian and commercial transport be conducted exclusively via helicopter services.

Based on the statement, which of the following logically follows?

  1. Only course of action I followsCevap
  2. B
    Only course of action II follows
  3. C
    Both courses of action I and II follow
  4. D
    Neither course of action I nor II follows

Cevap

Only course of action I follows
Course of action I is a proportionate, proactive, and feasible administrative response. It prepares the state for the predicted natural disaster by organizing resources (machinery, medical camps, monitoring) to minimize damage and ensure quick recovery. It directly addresses the problem stated in the vulnerability report.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze the problem presented in the statement.
The problem is an exceptionally high risk of massive landslides on a critical highway due to the upcoming monsoon season.
Understanding the exact nature and severity of the threat is required to accurately evaluate the proposed solutions.
2
Evaluate Course of Action I for feasibility and proportionality.
Positioning machinery, setting up medical camps, and monitoring the area mitigates the danger without unnecessarily halting essential life and commerce.
A valid course of action must practically address the problem, prepare for contingencies, and minimize overall harm.
3
Evaluate Course of Action II for feasibility and proportionality.
Permanently shutting down the highway and forcing helicopter transport is economically devastating and logistically impossible for a whole region.
Courses of action that introduce extreme, disproportionate, or impossible conditions are logically invalid as administrative policies.
4
Select the correct option based on the evaluations.
Only the first action is sound. Therefore, only the option specifying course of action I is correct.
Matching the logical evaluation of the actions to the provided choices.

Anahtar Kavram

Evaluating Administrative Responses for Proportionality and Feasibility
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Course of Action

Bu konudan daha fazla soru