Question

Difficulty: HardEvaluating Relevance for Adding or Deleting Content

Before the late nineteenth century, timekeeping was a local affair, with each town setting its clocks by the sun. In 1883, major railroad companies in North America agreed to establish four standard time zones to prevent scheduling confusion and train collisions. Under this new system, millions of travelers and businesses could coordinate their activities across vast distances. The Canadian railway engineer Sir Sandford Fleming, who first proposed worldwide hourly standard time zones, was knighted by Queen Victoria for his achievements. By 1918, the United States Congress had officially adopted standard time, cementing standard time zones as a permanent fixture of modern life.

The writer is considering deleting the underlined sentence. Should the sentence be kept or deleted?

  1. A
    Kept, because it introduces a key figure responsible for the global adoption of the time system mentioned throughout the passage.
  2. B
    Kept, because it explains the connection between the establishment of local timekeeping and the rise of international railway systems.
  3. C
    Deleted, because it contradicts the passage's assertion that timekeeping was primarily a local, solar-based system before the late nineteenth century.
  4. Deleted, because it shifts the focus of the paragraph from the practical coordination and adoption of standard time zones to biographical trivia about Fleming.Answer

Answer

Deleted, because it shifts the focus of the paragraph from the practical coordination and adoption of standard time zones to biographical trivia about Fleming.
The paragraph discusses the practical coordination and official adoption of standard time zones in North America. The underlined sentence introduces biographical trivia about Sir Sandford Fleming's knighthood, which shifts the paragraph's focus away from its main topic. Therefore, the sentence should be deleted.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the main topic of the paragraph.
The paragraph is about the coordination and adoption of standard time zones in North America to resolve railway scheduling issues.
Establishing the central theme of the surrounding text is necessary to determine what information is relevant.
2
Analyze the function of the underlined sentence.
The underlined sentence provides information about Sir Sandford Fleming proposing worldwide hourly time zones and being knighted by Queen Victoria.
Identifying the role of the sentence allows for comparing it against the paragraph's overall focus.
3
Compare the sentence's function with the paragraph's theme to make the final decision.
The sentence shifts focus to biographical trivia about Fleming, interrupting the discussion of North American implementation, so it should be deleted.
Sentences that distract from the main focus of a paragraph should be removed to maintain unity and cohesion.

Key Concept

Evaluating sentence relevance based on paragraph focus and unity.
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question