Question

Difficulty: MediumAnalogous Relationships

In temperate marine ecosystems, the interactions among sea otters, sea urchins, and giant kelp forests demonstrate the profound impact of a trophic cascade. Kelp forests serve as a vital marine habitat, but they are constantly threatened by herbivorous sea urchins that feed aggressively on kelp holdfasts. Fortunately, sea otters prey on these urchins, maintaining their numbers at a level that prevents them from overgrazing the kelp. When sea otters are hunted to near extinction, the urchin population expands exponentially, rapidly deforesting the seabed and turning a diverse habitat into a barren wasteland. In this relationship, the predator's pressure on a consumer indirectly safeguards the primary producer, preserving the entire ecological community.

Which of the following situations is most analogous to the relationship between the sea otters, sea urchins, and giant kelp forests described in the passage?

  1. A
    A commercial landlord offers discounted rent to a popular coffee shop because its daily foot traffic attracts customers who then patronize adjacent retail stores.
  2. B
    A city constructs a concrete seawall along the coast to block high tides from flooding low-lying residential neighborhoods during major storms.
  3. A government watchdog agency caps the transaction fees charged by payment processors, preventing them from depleting the narrow profit margins of independent merchants who sustain a community’s commercial district.Answer
  4. D
    A school board hires additional guidance counselors to directly assist students struggling with academic stress, thereby improving overall graduation rates.

Answer

The situation where a government watchdog agency caps transaction fees charged by payment processors to protect independent merchants who sustain a commercial district.
The correct answer is correct because it mirrors the three-part regulatory relationship in the passage. Just as sea otters (regulator) prey on sea urchins (consumer) to prevent them from destroying kelp forests (foundation), the watchdog agency (regulator) caps the fees of payment processors (consumer) to prevent them from destroying independent merchants (foundation) who sustain the commercial district.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the primary entities and the structure of their relationships in the passage.
Sea otters (regulator) prey on sea urchins (consumer) to prevent them from overgrazing and destroying giant kelp forests (the foundational habitat).
To establish the underlying logical schema of the cascade.
2
Abstract the relationship into a functional formula.
Entity A regulates Entity B to prevent Entity B from destroying Entity C, which is essential to the stability of the system.
To find a parallel scenario that shares this structural dynamic without using the same surface domain (marine biology).
3
Evaluate the options to find the one that matches this abstract three-part regulation.
The option featuring the watchdog agency (Entity A) regulating payment processors (Entity B) to protect independent merchants (Entity C) shares this exact logical structure.
To select the correct analogy.

Key Concept

Analogous relationships require identifying the underlying structural framework of a described scenario and matching it to a different scenario with different surface details but the same logical interactions.
Rate this question